Hybrid presentation by Luis Miguel Selvelli: ‘Brotherhood Across the Mediterranean: Italian Freemasonry and the Ottoman Mission of 1910’, 28 October 2025 - flyer: - slides:
1- In 2022 you published the book ‘Ancestors in Constantinople. Italian Exiles in the Age of Ottoman Reforms 1828-1878’ in Italian. Was your realisation of this Ottoman mission to Italy of 1910 uncovered during the research for that book and then did you decide to dig deeper into this forgotten episode when the two countries seemed so close in political vision, both hemmed-in by big power politics of the time?
No, my discovery about the mission happened in early 2022, while digging into the collection of Rivista Massonica (for the years 1880-1910) held at the Feltrinelli archive in Milano, for the purpose of preparing the biographic article about the Risorgimento fighter, freemason and pioneer of homeopathy in the Ottoman empire Anacleto Cricca, which is included in the book Smirne e l’Italia. Comunità, relazioni, istituzioni (ETP Books, Athens 2022) that I co-edited with Francesco Pongiluppi. I then started to dig deeper into it in 2023, also in the wider context of my research for the new book I am preparing, dedicated to the period 1890-1923.
2- In your ‘Antenati a Costantinopoli’ book the final chapters focus on the role played by some Italians affiliated to Istanbul’s Masonic lodges in the dramatic events that brought to the deposition of Sultan Abdulaziz in 1876 and the enthronement of Murat V with the aim of establishing a constitutional monarchy and a parliament, followed three months later by the coming to power of Abdulhamid that somehow marked the end of an epoch. Do you think the Masonic connections between these 2 nations was critical in arranging this May 1910 trip and do you think industrial links and investment also closely followed by those social alliances formed?
Yes, as I tried to explain in my presentation, Masonic connections were crucial in re-establishing good relations between Italy and the Ottoman empire after the political shock of the 1908 revolution. However, it is difficult to establish any sort of connection between these events and the 1876 Constitutional reform. In that previous occasion the role of Italian lodges was much more marginal and limited only to a couple of individuals. Also we should not forget that since the early years of Abdulhamid’s reign Masonic activity in the Ottoman empire came to an almost total halt due to the Sultan’s extreme paranoia and control on any sort of associational activity. In fact in the early 1880s the Italian Grand Orient prefered to formally “freeze” all sort of activities in the Ottoman territories, and then decided to secretly bring the lodges back to life in the early 1900s.
3- The Italian Ambassador to the Ottoman Empire between July 1904 and March 1910, di Francavilla, was very unhappy from the start and hated what he perceived as the ‘Byzantine intrigues’ of the capital. Yet around the same arrival date of that Ambassador the Italian Giovanni Romei Longhena was appointed in a junior role to help reorganise Ottoman gendarmerie particularly with a focus on the chaotic region of Macedonia. He soon became a favourite of the Sultan but straight after the Young Turks revolution abruptly left the country and caused damage to the diplomatic influence of the Italians not helped also by the Italians facilitating the escape of some Ottoman officials who were high up in the former regime. Do you see a degree of Italian diplomacy being usurped by this junior official because of the disinterest of the official ambassador, and presumably lax oversight from Rome, leading to this negative outcome?
I think this question would need a much more detailed research by a historian of diplomacy to be answered properly. But from my point of view I can say that yes, there was definitely something awkward in allowing a minor figure like Longhena to exert such a relevant role in the international relations between the two countries.
I guess that at the Italian Ministry of Foreign Affairs they were surprised by this exceptional intimacy developed by Longhena with the Sultan in such a short span of time, but they also thought that it was an opportunity to exploit in order to increase Italian influence in the Ottoman capital, which had been rather weak if compared to the position of the other Great powers in that period.
4- The Young Turk revolution of 1909 and Ottoman - Italy relations by the influence of Longhena had a rocky start. Yet within a year this mission of friendship took place. Was the earlier help of the Italian Freemasonry to the Young Turks crucial in helping mend bridges and were there main figures in this you can identify?
Yes, as I have already explained. Regarding the main figures involved in these connections, they are undoubtedly Emanuele Carasso in Salonica, Edoardo De Nari in Istanbul, and Ettore Ferrari in Rome.
5- The Venice based mission of ‘Museo Commerciale’ was established a year before the revolution, so it didn’t start from an ideological prompt unlike the Italian-Ottoman committee, which also sought to increase trading contacts with the East. Does the monthly publication of this earlier institution reveal the type of ongoing trade and did it include suggestions of new opportunities with the ‘Orient’ markets which included the Ottoman Empire?
Yes, the publication is an extraordinary source of information about the economic relations between Italy and the Ottoman empire, and every issue includes very valuable data about different aspects of Ottoman economy: agriculture, industrial production, raw materials, etc…
Yes, the publication is an extraordinary source of information about the economic relations between Italy and the Ottoman empire, and every issue includes very valuable data about different aspects of Ottoman economy: agriculture, industrial production, raw materials, etc…
6- Primo Levi (1853-1929) was an intellectual ‘man of letters’ who gradually drifted into diplomacy and was appointed Italian Consul in Salonica in 1909, that was still under Ottoman control. He was instructed by the newly appointed Minister of Agriculture, Industry & Commerce, Luigi Luzzatti to organise the mission of 1910. Clearly Levi was an efficient organiser but did he bring all the various parties and organisations together under his direction or was it a more collaborative process where organisations were brought in, but each retained their own agenda?
I would love to be able to answer, but this aspect of the organization would need further research about this extremely interesting figure and the relatively short but very intense period during which he was active as Italian consul in Salonica.
7- The head of the Ottoman mission was Nessib Bey who was formerly director of agricultural works in the province of Salonica. Do you think it is surprising that it was not a higher member of the Young Turks who headed this mission?
Yes, it is somehow surprising, and there may be many different causes for the Young Turks’ decision to maintain a low political profile by appointing a minor figure like Nessib Bey as head of the mission. For now I can only say that also this topic definitely needs further research in order to understand what was the process that brought to his appointment.
8- There are 123 names listed with professions for the visiting Ottoman group, but not all are industrialists and there was one general, Huseyin Husnu Pasha. He was instrumental in the mobilisation a year earlier of the Young Turks army of Macedonia to crush the counter revolution and shortly after that event was appointed the vali of Trablusgarb province and relations were good with the Italian authorities. However a year after this he is replaced by Ibrahim Edhem Pasa who was uncooperative with Italian demands and this eventually led to war. Why were the Italians so demanding in gaining additional trading access to that province or was it a game to create a future pretext for war and invade Ottoman lands in North Africa.
Even if in the very last phase some individual figures may have directly pushed for war, in more general terms the conflict was the result of a process that lasted around 15 years. Many valuable books and studies have been dedicated to this topic, but in order to keep it simple and short I think we can reduce the whole process to these 3 main factors:
- economic: shortly after the unification of Italy, a relevant process of emigration started to take place, due to the lack of economic resources in a country that was going through a demographic boom. The U.S.A was a main pole of attraction, followed by Latin America and other European countries. But Italian public opinion soon started to perceive this phenomenon as a humiliation and a real human tragedy, due to the fact that families were torn apart and often doomed not to meet anymore with their beloved ones after their departure to the American continent. For this reason a strong public opinion movement started to take shape claiming that Italy needed to find some “empty and underdeveloped land” (as they considered Libya) where Italians could work and take advantage of neglected resources, while at the same time keeping close to their country.
- symbolic: In the early 1890s Italy had tried to become a colonial power by occupying territories in Eastern Africa. But these attempts turned out to be pretty unsuccessful, culminating in March 1896 in a terrible military defeat in which at least 5,000 Italian soldiers perished in a dramatic battle against Ethiopian forces in the area of Adwa. This defeat marked the end of Italian colonial ambitions in East Africa and was perceived in Italy as a national shame that needed to be avenged as soon as possible.
- political: the early 1900s saw the steady growth of two political movements that had not existed until that moment in unified Italy: the Catholic and the Nationalist. Despite being very different from one another, starting in early the 1910s these two political currents overlapped and created a perfect storm that in less than two years was able to convince a relevant share of public opinion that the occupation of Libya was not only necessary but also perfectly meaningful (in opposition to the old “liberal” establishment and the strong socialist movement).
9- 16 months after this mission there was the Italian – Ottoman war over Libya that lasted just over a year in which Italy emerged victorious. Was there no calculation from the Italian side on the downsides of capturing a mostly desert territory and losing so much soft power and trade with the Ottoman Empire? What were the consequences to the significant Italian Levantine community resident for a long period in Ottoman ports?
Yes of course, it is clear from the diplomatic archives and correspondences that these calculations had been made and they were generally strongly opposed to such a military operation, deemed as risky, irrational and harmful to the Italian interests in the Levant. However, it is incredible to witness how in just no more than 8-9 months the current starts to change, pushed by the perfect political storm I mentioned before and the strong effect of newspapers. At the beginning you can see that it was only the Catholic and the Nationalist outlets that pushed for the war, but gradually also some more established newspaper started to take more ambiguous positions, and in the end it appears that the Prime minister Giolitti (the most important representative of the liberal establishment of those years) just could not avoid being swallowed by this maelstrom in which almost everybody seems to be calling for war.
I think this should remind us of how easy it is to feed the “animal spirits” of the society, especially when the feeling of a “moral crusade” is involved.
10- You have found a writing from Ahmet Emin, a journalist that was a member of this mission, and he stated ‘the Italians were cheating on us’, a harsh opinion of course. Do you think this sense of betrayal and disappointment could be expanded to the perception amongst members of the Young Turks who looked favourably at the British / French, but these countries unlike Germany didn’t provide material and moral support to the Young Turk movement?
There are many nuances in the individual reactions of all different Young Turks, especially the ones who were more active in cultural production and political criticism. But in general we can say that yes, the disappointment and feeling of having been betrayed by what they deemed as their political and cultural points of reference (especially Great Britain and France) played a crucial role in shaping the ideological process that led to the end of the Ottoman empire and the foundation of the Turkish republic during the dramatic years between 1912-1922.
