Prof Muhammed Hasanov hybrid lecture: ‘From Merchant Consuls to the Caliph's Representatives: The Transformation of the Ottoman Consulates in Liverpool and Manchester, 1891-1914’, 14 September 2026 - flyer:

Prof Muhammed Hasanov hybrid lecture: ‘From Merchant Consuls to the Caliph's Representatives: The Transformation of the Ottoman Consulates in Liverpool and Manchester, 1891-1914’, 14 September 2026 - flyer:

1- The Russia-Ottoman war of 1877-78 ended in a complete defeat for the Ottoman forces and most of the Balkans gained independence or autonomy close to independence for others (such as Bulgaria). Clearly, the Sultan of the time Abdulhamit II would have been furious with this outcome and the Empire afterwards became a clear Muslim majority population but with still large minorities of Greeks and Armenians. Was the pan-Islamist agenda a gradual ‘hardening’ of policies as a backlash to continued territorial losses or was it more a ‘glory’ project to make the Khalifate a universal one beyond the Ottoman Empire, and thus helping to weaken potential adversaries such as Britain and France (and Russia to some extent) who held sway over vast Muslim populations in their empires?
I believe it was more of a glory project, in which the Sultan wanted to emphasise his power as Caliph over Muslims across the world and use it as diplomatic leverage against the Great Powers. Therefore, the threat of using his authority as Caliph was more significant than actually exercising it.
2- In 1810 the Ottoman Jew jewellery merchant, Morris Lewin Mozley was appointed as the first consul in Liverpool, not that much after Yusuf Agâh Efendi, the first Ottoman ambassador to London in 1793 (the consulate 1806). Was the Liverpool consul what you would call today an ‘honorary’ consul, so a non-paid status or properly set up with its own building, as far as you know?
All Ottoman Consuls until the appointment of Dimitri Movrokordato served in an honorary capacity. During the early stages of Ottoman consular representation, consular appointments were predominantly honorary, with individuals generally selected from among the merchant community. It was not until the 1830s that the Ottoman Empire began to establish a system of salaried consular appointments.
3- The Ottoman populations of Britain in the 18th and 19th centuries were almost exclusively non-Moslem, so it made sense for the consuls in Liverpool to be from those ethno-religious groups as well. From 1891 things changed radically, and only Muslims were henceforth to be appointed as consuls in Britain. Was this change of hiring and firing across the board in Ottoman institutions both within and beyond the empire?
Not really. Despite the Sultan’s concerns about the Armenian question and his willingness to seek the support of both his Muslim subjects and Muslims all across the world, there were still non-Muslim bureaucrats within the Ottoman bureaucracy. The change was a slow process.
4- The Ottoman consul for Liverpool for more than 30 years was Pierre Mussabini, appointed in 1850, so clearly he was good at his job. Do we know much about him?
Yes, as a result of my PhD research, I have managed to gather a significant amount of information about Pierre Augustus Mussabini (1817–1898). He was born in Smyrna (modern-day Izmir) in 1817 and came from a merchant family originally from Damascus. He was appointed Ottoman Vice-Consul in Liverpool in 1847 and subsequently promoted to Consul in 1849. Alongside his consular duties, he was actively involved in maritime trade through the Papayanni & Mussabini Shipping Company. During the Crimean War, he assisted Ottoman naval vessels visiting Liverpool and arranged the burials of Ottoman sailors who died there. In recognition of his services, he was awarded the Order of the Medjidie. He continued serving as Ottoman Consul until 1886, making him one of the longest-serving Ottoman consular representatives in Britain.
5- In 1886, the Ottomans appointed the next consul (clearly now elevated to ‘general’) for Liverpool the aristocrat Dimitri Mavragordato. The illustration you show of him is a newspaper cutting under the title of ‘A polyglot interview’. Were you able to read this interview and was it illuminating in terms of his selection and roles he undertook in that position?
Yes, I have managed to read, you to have better idea I am textualizing of aforementioned article. “D. MAVROCORDATO EFFENDI”.
A Polyglot Interview.
THE CONSUL GENERAL FOR TURKEY IN LIVERPOOL.
The most familiar language of the Turkish Consul is Greek, and in this tongue our interview was mainly carried on through the aid of his secretary, who, though a young Englishman, spoke Greek fluently. Occasional lapses into sentences of French and English between the Consul and myself made the affair quite a polyglot interview. The Turkish Consul is quite a young man, only thirty years old; but I must let him speak for himself.
“You are of course a Turk?” I observed by way of opening the conversation.
“I am a Turk by nationality, being born in Constantinople; but my parents were Greek and I am a Greek by religion.”
“How long have you been in Liverpool, and how does Liverpool, for example, differ from Constantinople?”
“I have been in Liverpool fifteen months. As to the difference between Liverpool and Constantinople, that wants explanation. Constantinople is divided into two quarters—there is the Turkish quarter at Istambul, and the European quarter at Pera. These two localities are separated by the Golden Horn about which you hear so much in England. There is a more European aspect in Pera than in Istambul, but altogether Constantinople is very much European. The private houses of the well-to-do are like the English houses, but taller. About fifteen rooms are the fewest generally found in good houses, though they are not so comfortable as in England. The streets are long and wide though they are in bad order during the winter, and the shops are good; the same as here and elsewhere. All the higher classes wear European clothes with the exception of the fez. The poor people still wear the native costume.”
“What about the bazaars we hear spoken of so often?”
“Oh, the bazaars are long out of date and are replaced by European shops. A few of the old bazaars remain, but only as curiosities. They are very magnificent.”
“But how about the poor? How do they live?”
“The poor, as anywhere else, live as best they can, unfortunately. There are, perhaps, more beggars in the streets than anywhere else, the bridge across the Golden Horn from Istambul to Pera in particular being most crowded with them, and they are only too both there and in the streets. The Government has, however, sent a lot of them into the interior of Asia.”
“But what is the cause of this poverty? Do you mean that the working classes are beggars? Are there no national industries?”
“No; the working classes are not beggars; only those are beggars who are not willing to work. But there is not the same outlet for labour as in European countries, though parts of our navy is built in the waters of the Golden Horn and that gives some work.”
“If your navy is built there your merchantmen should be built there also, because it is much easier to build merchantmen than men of war.”
“No; the merchantmen are not built in Turkey; they are ordered from England.”
“But how is that?”
“There is not the capital or convenience in Turkey for great national manufacturing industries such as you have here. The working classes in Constantinople are in possession of minor trades. In the country they are engaged in agriculture, in growing fruit, coffee, gums, wine (which latter is sent to France and manufactured into Bordeaux), Valonias, indigo, corn, canary seed, &c., while far in the interior there are rich mines of silver, copper, and coal.”
“With such productive wealth as this Turkey ought to be rich?”
“Yes; but the means of communication leave much to be desired; we lose the benefit of these natural advantages. For instance, it is easier at present to import corn into Constantinople from Russia and Roumania than from the interior of Turkey. There is great wealth in the interior, but in some parts of the Empire, these products are carried painfully to the ports through the want of the necessary means of transports. Besides the existing railways there are needed still some 2,000 or 3,000 miles long in order to complete the communications for the commercial development of the Empire. I may add that for this purpose an American syndicate of capitalists has been formed in order to foster and promote this project, and almost every day the contract between the parties is expected to be signed. There is working at this moment a line between Constantinople and Tatar Bazardjik, and another one between Salonica and Mitrovitza. This last one will undoubtedly increase the trade of Turkey as well as probably take, for Salonica, a great part of the transit which now goes through Brindisi and Triest.”
“Do you expect that the railway to the interior will do much to solve the problem of Turkish poverty?”
“The word poverty is rather misplaced. But anyhow the projected railways will do much to increase the wealth of the population especially in the interior of the Empire.”
“What do the people of Turkey think of the name, ‘Sick Man,’ which we Europeans have given to your country?”
“Smiling: ‘People used to talk about the “Sick Man” at the time of the Crimea; but since, and particularly in 1877, Turkey showed she was no sick man—she had’t lost her fighting power.’”
“Is there in Turkey no yearning, as in England and other countries, for the progress of the people to a higher stage of national development; do they not want to move on?”
“Of course there is that feeling. But Turkey is held fast by the Europeans; if she moves they think they must interfere. If left alone she would go on better.”
“How is your government in Turkey. Is it despotic?”
“It is autocratic as in Russia. The nation is governed by the cabinet and the cabinet is selected by the Sultan. But he selects his ministers according to the political requirements of the time.”
“Has he the power of life and death?”
“No; his power is limited. There are the ‘Sheik’ the same as in Europe; there is no difference. The law in Turkey is the Code of Napoleon.”
“Were you educated at Constantinople?”
“I was educated in Constantinople at the University and also at the École de Droit at Paris, being intended for the diplomatic service my main study was law.”
“Is the curriculum the same in Turkey as in Europe?”
“Our studies are pretty much the same.”
“Can you give us a brief outline of your career in the diplomatic service?”
“My first year I spent as attaché at the foreign office, Constantinople, and then spent three years as attaché at the Turkish Embassy at Paris. On leaving Paris I was appointed first secretary at Belgrade, where I remained four years and then came to Liverpool fifteen months ago. There was a good deal of business going on when I was at Belgrade, where there are a lot of Turkish subjects, Nisch, Vrania, Lescovatz, and Pirot belonged to Turkey, but the Berlin Conference handed them over to Servia. By the loi agraire the Turkish landholders were compelled to sell out to Servian farmers which caused much trouble. At first Turkey would not accept this law and protested. Then a Servian commission was formed to value the lands. They, however, made whatever estimate pleased them and the disputes arising out of this had to be settled at the embassy.”
“What about political matters in Servia?”
“I do not know what you mean by political matters. As regards the population of Servia, I can only say that the bulk are Russophiles at heart, and as to the late war, my impression is that the first move of Servia was to attack elsewhere, but finding that it was too much for her, and having put herself in a very critical situation with her expensive preparations, she thought it reasonable to do what she did.”
“Have you been on any special missions of interest?”
“Of interest, no; but when at Paris, I accompanied our Ambassador to Spain to present King Alfonso with a Turkish decoration, the Osmanie in Brilliants; and in Servia I was sent several times into the interior on matters concerning the Turkish subjects.”
“What is your impression of Paris?”
“Paris is a nice place to enjoy yourself in, but there is no place in the world with such natural beauty as Constantinople, with the Bosphorus.”
“Are there no incidents of your Paris experience worth relating?”
“Political incidents I cannot speak of; some private ones (en riant), perhaps, might interest you.””
6- You made a distinction of 2 forms of ‘pan-Islamism’. In the first instance you describe that form as anti-imperialist and in the second anti-nationalist and you put the Abdulhamit’s 2nds in the second category. The idea is for the Ottomans to survive in the predatory world of big powers, the Muslims within the Empire, including Albanian, Kurds, Arabs etc. needed to unite under a common banner. The Sultan was shrewd enough not to call for a global Jihad. So, do you think the Sultan knew the limits the foreign powers would allow for external meddling, and this was calibrated to be a more an internal policy?
Yes, I believe that the Sultan’s pan-Islamism was primarily intended to protect the interests of the Ottoman Empire and prevent its further disintegration by threatening the external powers with the possibility of using his authority as Caliph.
7- The result of the new pan-Islamist policy led presumably the loss of a huge talent pool through the marginalisation of non-Muslims from positions of influence and thus perhaps considered a minor price to pay. Was the new convert to Islam, Abdullah Quillian a lucky benefactor of this wind of change, yet without the Islamic credentials of knowledge of Arabic and Islamic tradition, but made up for those shortcoming by being positioned at a crucial port?
Yes, Quilliam was even more advantageous than non-Muslim diplomats, as he had considerable experience as both a journalist and a lawyer. Therefore, he could protect the Ottoman Empire’s image, which had been severely damaged by the Armenian events, and also defend its interests internationally.
8- Abdullah Quillian published 2 Islamic magazines, ‘the Crescent’ and ‘the Islamic World’. Were you able to examine them and were they concerning the teachings of Islam in English, or did they also include ‘community news’ to help you build a picture of their flock?
Yes, I have managed to examine those newspapers. There are a few references to the teachings of Islam, but the magazines were heavily influenced by politics, focusing primarily on protecting Ottoman interests.
9- You didn’t talk much on the Manchester Ottoman consulate. Was its history similar to Liverpool with pre 1891 being non-Muslim, post only Muslims appointed? How different was the composition of the Manchester Ottoman community versus Liverpool?
Before 1891, there were some striking differences between Manchester and Liverpool. The vice-consul appointed to Manchester in 1846 was, in fact, a 26-year-old Muslim Ottoman subject, Abdullah Ydlibi, who had worked as a diplomat in the Ottoman Ministry of Foreign Affairs for five years before arriving in Manchester. However, the appointment of a Muslim vice-consul was not a deliberate choice, as religious affiliation was not a primary concern of the Ottoman authorities at the time. In terms of the composition of the Ottoman communities, there were also striking differences between Liverpool and Manchester. In Liverpool, most Ottoman subjects were involved in the shipping business, whereas in Manchester, Ottoman subjects were predominantly Armenians engaged in the cotton trade. This difference in commercial activities was also reflected in the professional backgrounds of the Ottoman consuls. In Liverpool, Pierre Mussabini owned a shipping company, while in Manchester, Abdullah Ydlibi operated an import-export company.
10- During Abdullah Quillian’s extended visit to Istanbul, Ismail Hakki Bey, the young Ottoman diplomat and future prime minister, was appointed as his guide for ‘necessary guidance so that he could truly serve the Sultan in the future’. Can you describe this as part of Ottoman counter propaganda and image management at a time when British newspapers were reporting on massacres against Bulgarians and Armenians? Do you think he was able to perform that duty to any degree of significance in a Victorian society perhaps suspicious of the motives of a convert? Do we know of definite converts to Islam in Liverpool beyond family members of the congregation; have listings of names survived?
Yes, I describe the guidance provided by İsmail Hakkı Bey as part of the Ottoman Empire’s counter-propaganda and image-management efforts, through which the Ottoman authorities sought to use Abdullah Quilliam, who was also a journalist, to defend Ottoman interests. I believe that Quilliam was quite successful at the local level, publishing a considerable number of articles in the local press. However, his activities did not extend significantly beyond Liverpool, as most of his writings appeared in local newspapers. Although his own periodicals reached Muslim readers in different parts of the world, I would argue that their circulation remained relatively limited.
There were also several identifiable converts to Islam associated with the Liverpool Muslim community, including: Walid F. Preston, O. Khalid Smith, Bilal Wilkinson, Djem Ali Hamilton, Elizabeth Fatima Cates, H. Yehya Johnson and Michael Hall.
11- In 1891 the first Ottoman Muslim consul general for Liverpool was appointed, Ismail Lutfi (Simavi) who maintained a low profile. Do you think one of his tasks would have been reporting on any nationalistic movements within the Armenian communities or was this never an issue in Britain?
One of İsmail Lütfi Bey’s main responsibilities, alongside reporting on Liverpool’s Muslim community, was monitoring Armenian communities and nationalist activities in North West England.
12- You referred to Mehmet Kamil Bey, the 4th of the Muslim consuls for Liverpool as a ‘very interesting figure’, but what exactly in his nature made him stand out for you? He tried hard to establish a Muslim cemetery in Liverpool but failed for bureaucratic reasons and beyond the needs of Ottoman sailors etc. who died in port, do you think this was part of the mechanism to portray the Ottoman Sultan as the head of all Muslims in the world?
What makes Mehmed Kamil Bey particularly interesting is his active commitment to Sultan Abdülhamid II’s Pan-Islamic policies and his pragmatic approach to diplomacy. Before his appointment to Liverpool, he had served in Batavia, where he actively promoted Ottoman Pan-Islamism, established close relations with local Muslim communities, and arranged for several Muslim children to receive their education in Constantinople. His activities led to the dismissal form his post by the Dutch colonial authorities.
When he arrived in Liverpool in 1899, he adopted a similarly active approach. Unlike his predecessors, he developed close personal relations with Abdullah Quilliam and the Liverpool Muslim Institute, regularly attended community events, and sought to strengthen connections between Liverpool Muslims and Constantinople. He also arranged for Quilliam’s eldest son, Ahmed, to receive a scholarship to study in the Ottoman capital.
Regarding the Muslim cemetery, I would argue that Kamil Bey viewed the project as both a religious obligation and an opportunity to promote the Sultan’s authority as Caliph. In his report to the Sultan dated 12 August 1899, he emphasised that 44 Muslims were buried in Liverpool Necropolis, more than half of whom were Ottoman sailors who had died of cholera in 1856–1857. He described these sailors as martyrs and argued that establishing a Muslim cemetery would benefit not only the local Muslim community but also the wider Islamic world. Given Liverpool’s importance as an international port, he believed that such a project could reinforce the Sultan’s image as the protector of Muslims beyond the Ottoman Empire. However, despite his efforts, the project did not receive the necessary support from Constantinople and was never realised. Another interesting aspect of Kamil Bey’s character was his changing relationship with Quilliam. Although he initially regarded Quilliam as a valuable ally and even went beyond his consular jurisdiction to support him in personal matters, he gradually became critical of Quilliam’s activities. In his later reports, he accused Quilliam of exaggerating his achievements and exploiting Islam for personal gain. Nevertheless, he maintained cordial relations with him publicly, recognising his potential usefulness for Ottoman interests.
13- Abdullah Quillian’s mosque hosted would be Ottoman Muslim immigrants to the United States and Liverpool was a stop-over port and you mentioned in 1905 there was a spike in emigration particularly from Harput in the SE of the country. Do we know why this region at the time was the main source of these migrants and do we know if these Muslims were able to maintain a cohesive identity beyond a certain time after they reached the United States?
Ottoman Muslim migration to the United States was largely driven by economic hardship and the availability of better employment opportunities in America. Harput had already developed strong connections with the United States through Armenian migration and American missionary activities. Muslim migrants subsequently benefited from these established routes and networks. As for whether these migrants maintained a cohesive identity after arriving in America, the answer is yes, at least initially. Many Ottoman Muslim migrants from Harput settled in the same neighbourhoods, worked in leather factories and established coffeehouses and boarding houses that served as centres of communal life. Interestingly, their collective identity was often based more on their shared regional origins than on a broader Ottoman or Muslim identity. However, this cohesion was not necessarily permanent. Many migrants return home after accumulating sufficient savings in 1920s.
14- What were your chief sources of information and are there still archives you wish to access concerning this subject?
My chief sources of information were the Ottoman Archives and the National Archives at Kew, and I also hugely benefited from British newspapers and Abdullah Quilliam’s own magazines, The Crescent and The Islamic World.
15- Do you have a future research project in mind?
I am currently in contact with a publisher and plan to publish my PhD thesis as a book within the next year.