Anglo-Turkish Society

Professor Andrea U. De Giorgi & Professor Asa Eger online presentation: ‘Antioch through the Ages. Past, Present, and Future?’, 16 May 2023 - flyer:

Interview - (Professor Asa Eger’s responses in italics)

1- Where do we see the first accounts of the settlement on the site of Antioch and how early was this?

Antioch’s historical presentation appears first in the works of Strabo and Appian in the Roman imperial epoch. During Late Antiquity, Eusebius, Libanius and John Malalas, among others, elaborated on existing traditions, local legends, and personal experience.

2. How many new lives has this city had throughout history?

Hard to count. Four main bouts of construction spanned the foundation (300 BCE) and the building program of Antiochus IV Epiphanes (175-164 BCE). In true Roman fashion, many emperors stamped their own vision of the city, from Augustus to Trajan and all the way to Valens. Earthquakes contributed to relentless renovation. Ultimately Justinian reconfigured the city in the 6th century.

I would say most every period is a new life. For its medieval history, the Islamic period represented a change, though not dramatic. The Middle Byzantine did as well, and the Crusader period. The Mamluk period also was a sharp change or ‘new life’ and the Ottoman period was mostly a development of the Mamluk city.

3. What was the contemporary understanding of, and reaction to, the natural disasters that befell the city?

A mix of fear and sense of having wronged the gods. The dissemination of monumental talismans around the perimeter of the city betrays anxieties that loomed large for centuries. In the Christian era not much changed; the trope of the wrath of God resonates in the chronicles of the devastation caused by the earthquakes.

During much of the Byzantine period and even in Christian sources after that offer a retelling of earlier disasters, it was often framed as God being angry or displeased in some way. Sometimes this was aimed generally at Antioch's residents, or its Christian population, or specifically, one Christian community as opposed to another - particularly among the major schism of diaphysites and miaphysites.

4. Does the city have a ‘Golden Age’?

The fourth century AD, when prior to the foundation of Constantinople, Antioch time and again functioned as de facto capital of the Roman empire. Rome is where the Emperor is, says the adage. In that vein, frequent imperial sojourns made Antioch the center of the oikoumene.

5. What was the make-up of the urban population of the city and how did this change over time?

Jews, Arabs, Greeks, Armenians, Persians, Italians, Greeks: a conglomerate of Mediterranean and Oriental communities. Many of these ethnicities are attested to by the (modest) epigraphic record and have left a profound imprint in the fabric of the city.

In medieval/Islamic periods, Antioch had growing Muslim populations but Christian majority populations (mostly miaphysite were visible in the Early Islamic period). Arabic and Greek were used. In the Middle Byzantine period, we begin to see Armenians. Jews were always present. Following, the Saljuqs bring a Turkish minority population to the city and of course we have Crusaders, who, for Antioch are mostly Normans from Sicily in power with Latin and they are western Christians, not Orthodox. The Mamluks once again bring a new ruling population of Turks and Circassians as do the Ottomans. From the Crusader period we have evidence of Venetian, Amalfi, and Genoese - Italian merchants setting up trading colonies. It always has a mixed religious and ethnic population.

6. What drew you both to this project of writing a biography of Antioch?

We started working on Antioch more than twenty years ago, as we completed the archaeological survey of the Amuq Valley, that is the plan of Antioch and adjacent districts. Documenting a city that for decades had been treated as a “textual” entity has been our main driver.

Andrea and I have worked in Antioch since 2001 and 2002. We have lived in the city and worked in and around it. We have always been drawn to the city and its inhabitants, past and present. We have also been heavily involved in Princeton’s excavations from the 1930s. After more than 20 years, the city is like a second home. Aside from that, we felt that the flurry of research now on Antioch begged for a new history, one that updates what Downey wrote in the early 60s and which was problematic for its omission of anything really after the Islamic conquests. We wrote this to establish a new baseline for Antioch research with a history that is far more comprehensive from its founding to the modern period.

7. What kind of sources have you used during your research and where can they be found?

We drew upon a century or so of scholarship, primarily textual. We added archaeological data either collected by us, or recent German and Turkish surveys. Also, we greatly harnessed the datasets of the archaeological excavation of Antioch, 1932-39. The legacy data stemming from the early exploration of the city, in particular, have been pivotal in rebuilding a sense of topography. That same topography is now accessible through our website thanks to our colleagues at Princeton, Toronto, and Chicago.

We make use of all kinds of archaeological material, both new and from Princeton’s 1930s excavations (a lot from then). We also have included as many textual sources as possible from every period - histories, letters, treaties, travel guides, poetry, and more. We have used a lot of evidence from coins (numismatics) in describing the economy and inscriptions as well. Lastly, we make use of evidence from archaeological projects around and geomorphology to produce a picture of the landscape around.

8. Reflecting on the process of researching and creating the book, what advice do you have for scholars undertaking similar projects?

Compressing thousands of years of history and materiality is a complicated task; shifting the pendulum away from kings and emperors and focusing on the local community and its sense of adaptation through the centuries is the best advice.

I would love to see full history biographies of many cities. Ones that start with foundations and move to modern periods and take into account material and textual sources. I think scholars who have worked around ancient and medieval cities for most of their careers ought to undertake such biographies. They are immensely helpful and rewarding.

9. With the recent natural disasters the city has recently suffered again, where do you think the story of Antioch will go next?

The Tyche, that is the divine fortune of the city, will no doubt rise once again from her ashes.

10. What is next for your research?

Antioch’s suburb of Daphne (Harbiye) is next; at this time we are culling thousands of files from the 1932-39 excavations, writing the history of the excavations, and producing the first ever topography of the site.

Questions by Gemma Masson, April 2024