Dr Benedek Péri online presentation: ‘Poetry and drugs in the Ottoman Empire in the 16th–17th centuries’, 7 February 2023 - flyer:
1- Can you share how you first became interested in researching the role of drugs in the Ottoman Empire?
During one semester I was planning to read Ottoman narrative poetry with my students. My choice fell on Muhammad Fuzuli’s Beng ü Bade (The Debate of Weed and Wine). While reading the text, I felt that the text contained many references to the drug culture of the time in the form of wordplays. In order to understand them, I started doing research on Ottoman drug culture.
2- What were the main sources you used in researching the this work?
My main sources were Ottoman literary texts from the 16th century, but I also used historical sources, and Chaghatay and Persian poetic texts well.
3- How was drug use seen in Ottoman society? Was it an elite pastime? Specifically artisic? Religious?
The use of drugs was not limited to the elite. However, social status seems to have played a key role in people’s choice of drugs. Cannabis was by used by members of qalandari spiritual communities as an entheogen, a psychedelic substance that helped them to reach an altered state of consciousness and have a spiritual experience. As cannabis grows wild in Anatolia and the drug does not require any special skills to make, it was mainly, but not exclusively, used by the poor because of its cheapness. Drugs prepared by specialists called maʿcūncıs had a higher price and were mainly consumed by people who had a steady income and thus could afford them. Berş-i Rahīkī a popular opium based electuary invented in the 16th century was for example mainly used by scribes and other educated people who fell into the category of çelebis.
4- How did the drugs you discuss compare to the role of tobacco in Ottoman Society and the changing, controversial opinions about it?
Contemporary sources suggest that while some drugs were legal and socially accepted, others, though never banned, were looked down upon. For example, consumers of opium and opium-containing drugs, like berş, were active participants in state festivities, but the same cannot be said of cannabis addicts. Tiryaki koşusu, the race of drugged and therefore stumbling opium eaters, or the scaring of drugged addicts with snakes and bears, was a popular spectacle. There is no record of such a practice in relation to cannabis consumers in contemporary sources. Tobacco arrived quite late in the Ottoman Empire, towards the end of the 16th century, perhaps through the British, and it became popular very fast. However, the secular authorities, perhaps to protect traditional agricultural production, banned not only smoking but also the cultivation and trade of tobacco. The ban remained in force until the middle of the 17th century, albeit in an increasingly lenient form, until 1688, when the government started to levy a tax on tobacco.
5- Can you say anything in relation to the role of coffee in Ottoman Society?
My research is focused mainly on 15th–16th century literary texts. Coffee became a popular beverage in the Ottoman Empire in the second half of the 16th century and Ottoman literature reflects this fact, as coffee begins to appear in literary texts in this period. Bâkî (d. 1600) was one of the outstanding gazel poets of the classical Ottoman literary tradition. He has a hemistich (half-line of verse) showing that coffee was consumed together with berş, an opium based designer drug in his times. Dil-i mahzûn bulurdı kahve vü berş ile Bâkî zevk. “Sorrowful hearts find pleasure in coffee and berş, Bâkî.” As berş was marketed in the form of sweet and soft pills, I suspect that the custom of serving Turkish coffee with a piece of lokum today is a remnant of this custom.
6- How about the alcohol consumption?
Though the consumption of alcohol is considered illegal in Islamic law, as the state had revenues from its production and sale, and wine was marketed in the Ottoman Empire. This business was mainly in the hands of Christians and Jews and wine was available to consumers at places like Tahtakale, the red-light district in Istanbul. However, from time to time a ban was imposed on alcohol as it happened in 1562. Bâkî composed a beautiful poem on the occasion Sultan Süleyman’s burning of the wine ships in the Golden Horn Bay. The gazel starts with the couplet Reh-i meyhâneyi katʿ etdi tîg-i kahrı sultânuñ/Su gibi arasını kesdi Sıtanbul u Kalatānuñ (“The sword of the wrath of the Sultan cut the road towards the taverns/Like the water, it separated Istanbul from Galata”).
7- What route did drugs take to their users? Who was involved in harvesting, processing, selling etc?
As Kaygusuz Abdal’s gazel mentioned in my lecture indicates hallucinogenic plants like cannabis could be collected in the wild. Drugs that required special skills to produce were prepared by professionals. Such professionals were called maʿcūncıs who not only made these drugs but also sold them in their shops. A group of gazels addressed to maʿcūncı beloveds give a good description of their shops and the products they sold. By the end of the 16th century, the demand for drugs had increased so much that factories with several employees were established. The small shop of Rahîkî, the inventor of a special concoction of berş called berş-i Rahîkî, also developed into a successful family enterprise that remained in the hands of his descendants until the late 18th century. As the Helvahâne defteri, the records of the royal kitchen responsible for the production of sweetmeats, confectionaries, jams and syrups indicate, the royal household’s demand for designer drugs were satisfied by the palace kitchen.
8- You said that cannabis never entered institutionalised Sufi Dervishism? Can you say a little more on why this was the case?
Instead of using entheogens, Orthodox spiritual dervish communities relied on other methods to attain an altered state of consciouness and induce a spiritual experience. The Halvetis and Mevlevis, for example achieved this altered spiritual state through music and rituals consisting of repetition of specific movements.
9- Can you speak a little more to the Indian connections that can be seen via spiritual cannabis consumption?
There are scholars who think the Kalenderî movement, to which Muslim sources link the use of cannabis, was born out of an interaction between groups of Muslim and Buddhist or Hindu mendicant ascetics. Ahmet Yaşar Ocak suggested that Buddhist mysticism might have also contributed to the shaping of Kalenderî thinking. Harriet Hartman compared the world view of Shaiva Hindu Kānphatā yogis and Muslim Kalenderî communities both of which, according to her, had originated in 12th century India. Athar Abbas Rizvi took the matter one step forward when he claimed that Haydarîs who were a subgroup of the Kalenderî movement, adapted the custom of passing an iron rod through their male organs in order to indicate “their determination to remain celibate” from Hindu Naga Sanyasis and aquired the practice of wearing an iron ear ring from Kānphatā yogis. The possibility that Kānphatā yogis might have in part influenced the evolution of the system of Haydarî customs takes us back to the issue of spiritually motivated cannabis consumption. Founded by Gorakhnath in the 12th century the Kānphatā school of thought belongs to Shaivite Nath Tantric traditions where cannabis and bhang, a cannabis based drink savoured by Shiva, the God of Tantra, had formed an inseparable part of religious rituals already in the 7th century. Thus it is not without reason to suggest that we should add another item to the list of customs Kutbuddin Haydar, the founder of the Haydarî community and his followers learnt from yogis. It is to rely on cannabis’ potential to enhance the sense of divine and help the devotee to attain a state of mind in which he “is able to keep his thoughts from straying off onto trivial or lustful topics”. In this “impersonal trance he becomes oblivious to mundane concerns”, his mind is emptied of “all worldly distractions” and he can think of only to the Divine.
10- Finally – what’s next for your research?
At the moment I am working on a book on various issues connected to imitation as as artistic creative method in 15th–16th century Turkic gazel poetry. The volume is going to contain chapters on the establishment of the three Turkic classical literary traditions (Chaghatay, Ottoman, Ajemi Turkic), on Turkic/Turkish gazel, on imitation and imitation networks and a case study on a huge Ottoman imitation network that started in the 16th century.