George Gawrych online lecture: ‘Ataturk: The Soldier-Statesman in the War of Independence’, 9 November 2021 - flyer:
1- Teaching at Baylor University Turkish officers who later rose the ranks to become generals allowed you the introduction to look into the Turkish military archives to study Ataturk and his military tactics. Was this a long-term game plan or a lucky result of you being in that teaching position and how unusual is it for these archives to be opened to foreigners? Are some of the archives in Turkey closed to foreigners and if so do you have to connect the dots using secondary sources?
The Turkish officers were at the U.S. Army Command and General Staff College (not Baylor) where I taught them. There was no long-range plan on my part. I decided not to maintain contacts with the officers after they returned to Turkey. There was no need to compromise their positions back home. During my visiting professorship at West Point (2002-03), I decided to try to return to academia and not go back to the staff college. Later, by chance, the son of one of the Turkish officers contacted me and connected me to his father, a major general by then. He knew the commandant of ATASE. Most archives are open today but certainly not the presidential archives.
2- Ataturk was clearly an intellectual driven by Enlightenment, science and rational thinking. Do you think his birthplace of Salonica in Ottoman Macedonia may have been a factor with its multi-confessional populations thus possibly deriving elements in his adolescence also from Greek and Bulgarian culture, so perhaps shielded by the more constricting Islamic outlook prevalent in Anatolia and Arabic speaking lands of the Ottoman Empire at the time?
Salonica possessed a rich and diverse culture, and Ataturk certainly benefited from it, especially when he enrolled in Semsi Efendi’s (a Donme) progressive school and then the military school. Ataturk developed a curious mind early on. A bad experience with his first teacher, a religious hoca, helped shape his attitude to Islam.
3- Your work derives heavily from the writings of Ataturk himself and so you get information right from the primary source effectively. He wrote in the period of March 1923, post ejecting the invading Greek army from Anatolia but before the signing of the treaty of Lausanne, ‘Perhaps more than reason, logic or judgement, what makes history are feelings / sentiments’. Clearly he is reflecting on the recent past as he steered his nation towards victory from a very shaky start. Do you think he retained a similar philosophy throughout his life as he later evolved to a civilian leader, so perhaps to sum it, to inspire people you need to understand their state of mind and from that motivate them to chime with their inner feelings?
Yes, indeed on the continuity. In my second book on Ataturk and the Republic still in draft form, I found a similar quote made publicly by him in 1925. Then in notes, I found an even stronger statement. His speeches often spoke of his emotional connection to the people. Even the Enlightenment had a place for emotions, depending on the writer. Science and reason were central, but so were conscience, emotions/sentiment, general knowledge and the fine arts.
4- Ataturk went to military staff college and you were able to access his notes and questions as well in the archives. Clearly his thinking was already evolving on matters such as the need for a superiority in political ideas to also win over populace and therefore wars. Do you think he was ‘ahead of the pack’ already by that stage?
Yes, I do. But he was not the only one. Experience helped develop the intellectual appreciation. And it was another matter to then become the political leader and the commander-in-chief in the full sense of field command.
5- Following the defeat in the Russo-Turkish War (1877–1878), Sultan Hamid, of the Ottoman Empire, asked for German help to reorganize the Ottoman Army, so that it would be able to resist the advance of the Russian Empire. Baron von der Goltz was sent. Do you think Goltz views on ‘nation in arms’ type of total war had a bearing on Ataturk’s own military thinking?
It became an ideal for him. The Ottoman imperial army was a multi-ethnic, multi religious, and polyglot institution. Before the Great War, Ataturk did write of the earlier glories of the then Turkish army. In the War of Independence, he appealed to Muslim nationalism, territorial patriotism, and conscience. More a people in arms. In the last year of the war, however, he appealed to Turkish nationalism. The national army and nation in arms developed during the Republic.
6- Ataturk seems to have placed a great importance in conscience and this seems to go counter to the Germanic military thinking probably prevalent at the time. Do we know what type of non-military books he read and do we know if he could read in foreign languages as well, where this emphasis of beyond reason and logic in terms of motivating people?
There is a 24-volume set in Turkish of books that Ataturk read. It contains copies of pages on which he made marks while reading. So, we do know what he read, both military and non-military subjects. Several volumes contain books in French. He also read translations. One count claims 3,995 books and how they break out according to subject.
879 history
535 literature
397 linguistics
261 military
197 political science
195 fine arts
187 applied sciences (medicine, engineering)
169 law
160 religion
139 economy
109 philosophy, metaphysics, psychology
104 hard sciences
101 education
75 sociology
33 biology
7- Did Ataturk ever have a major falling out with any of his generals during the war of independence or was he able through his genius make sure he was able to side-step a potentially damaging rift in such a critical time for the country? Was he a realist who never overplayed his hand for example by not attempting to capture the Deodocanese Islands under Italian control quite close to the Anatolian mainland?
He had tensions with some but for the most part they remained on board for the nationalist cause. Amphibious operations were out of mind and sight. Ataturk was a realist who made a good calculation on how far he could go with territorial aims. Those became clearer over time during the national struggle. For example, he left Hatay out of the picture and withdrew forces from Georgia.
8- The Sultan though in occupied Istanbul was still the nominal leader of the country and in 1920 parliament is opened, Kemalist deputies are voted in and the ‘national pact’ is accepted and then the British and French close the parliament sending a definite signal that they are not interested in a resurgent Turkey. Do you think this was an ‘own goal’ by the Allied powers and provided legitimacy for the nationalistic forces? Do you think the Allies had a rather arrogant colonial mindset?
I believe closing the Ottoman parliament and arresting deputies and then Ataturk reconstituting a representative-type assembly in Ankara was the turning point in the war. But Ataturk had to use his talents to make it so. Battle of Sakarya pretty much sealed the effort. Back to March 1920, the Allied capitals lacked an appreciation of this situation whereas senior commanders in Istanbul appeared troubled by the move. After all, the Allied powers were imposing their will in the Middle East and they had the sultan-caliph caged in Istanbul.
9- Do we know why Ataturk chose Ankara as the new capital when more substantial cities in Anatolia such as Kayseri, Sivas, Samsun etc. were also available? Or do you think starting from a minor town with no real local elite allowed for a clean slate to build the vision of a new nation?
Ataturk viewed Ankara as a strategic location because of its train connections and it was located close to the main threat coming from Greece. It became the symbol of the Turkish victory and center for building the new Turkey in Anatolia.
10- Between the defensive battle of Sakarya and the big offensive battle of Dumlupinar there is a gap around 1 year. Was Ataturk super cautious like Montgomery in El Alamein, attacking only when he had a clear superiority in men and materials?
Yes, he was restrained by the size of the army and its material. He felt a lack of experienced young officers. He also had to train the army for offensive operations and break a defensive mindset.
11- You are currently working on Mustafa Kemal Atatürk as president of the Republic, 1923 to 1938. When do you think this book will be published?
I hope to submit the final draft to the publisher by the end of April. If all goes well, the book should be out several months before 29 October 2023.
12- Ataturk saw himself as an educator and this comes through in his speeches which you will no doubt make use of them in your research for your upcoming book. Was he a master of language which then created the excitement for him to roll out the various revolutionary reforms in the republic?
Ataturk had an excellent command of the Ottoman imperial language. At times, he spoke above the heads of many in his audience. Reading Nutuk is tough in the original. At times, I felt he spoke and wrote like a poet in beautiful imagery and choice of words.