Anglo-Turkish Society

Online lecture: ‘Hagia Sophia in the light of Ottoman legends’, Doğukan Atmaca, 5 November 2020 - flyer:

1- Hagia Sophia clearly was already an ancient building even for the Byzantines at the time of the conquest. Do we have any handle on the specifics of Byzantine legends on its origins / pre-construction vision that the Ottomans then sought to weave into their own later narrative?

Yes. The Ottoman legends are translated/re-written versions of Byzantine history dealing legends called as “Patria”. Those chronicles talk about the city’s history such as the Life of Constantine the Great dated back to 12th -13th centuries, it was published by François Halkin. Stefanos Yerasimos, notes that the number of chronicles has increased during the late Byzantine time (14th century) while the Empire was shrinking. This suggests us that the value of Hagia Sophia in the eye of Byzantines increased as the Empire lost power.

2- Beyond being an amazing piece of architecture that withstood many earthquakes over centuries do we know much about the novel construction techniques or materials used by the architects that made this feat ‘well before its time’ feasible. Do we know if these architects perfected their art on this building or do we know of lesser buildings they worked on?

The architects of the 3rd Hagia Sophia, which is the present one, were Isidore of Miletus and Anthemius of Tralles, and previously they built Little Hagia Sophia Mosque (Church of Saints Sergius and Bacchus) which was much smaller scale of Hagia Sophia. They, possibly, tried the dome before the main project according to some art historians. However, even the dome of Hagia Sophia was not perfect, so it collapsed. Clearly, we owe the stability of it to Mimar Sinan (d. 1588) who supported the central dome by adding buttresses to the building.

3- Is there something particularly Islamic as in the scriptures that whoever conquers Constantinople will have done a great service to spreading and exulting that faith? And in this exultation was it vital for Sultan Mehmet the Conqueror to spare Hagia Sophia from the customary post-conquest sack so it could be dedicated both to Islam and his dual rule over that realm and the legacy Roman Empire as he saw it?

I have read and listened from some scholars that the hadith, word of Prophet Mohammad, about the conquest did not appear before the 15th century, but I do not really know about it. However, Mehmed II did not want city to be sacked at all, he probably hoped that the defenders would surrender, so that the city would not be sacked. As surrendering did not come from the Roman side, he had to allow his army to plunder the city. Sparing Hagia Sophia, surely, helps him for being the bearer of the Roman heritage.

4- Sultan Mehmet clearly was an intellectual and visionary and he obviously also laid the groundwork for a lot systems based on religious diversity within the Empire and for these communities to manage their own affairs with considerable autonomy. Do you think the decision not to cover the Christian frescoes within Hagia Sophia was a dual signal both to the remaining Orthodox community that their heritage wouldn’t be completely erased so they had security within the Empire and also perhaps a message to the new Moslem inhabitants not to antagonise the minorities as they were essential to keep trade and activity within this new capital?

We should add into the account that Mehmed was also a patron of arts, so it would not be wrong to assume that he appreciated the artistic value of those work. Furthermore, can we argue that the Muslims did not mind having images while praying as long as they did not worship to them? Also, we should consider that there were many converts who were familiar with those frescos, not covering them should have made them feel comfortable. On the other hand, I would assume the new Muslim inhabitants also familiar with such Christian art in Anatolia and the Balkans. This needs further research to understand.

5- Mehmet the Conqueror seems to have a good network of tutors and advisors to make him the man he became. Do we know much about this group mentors?

We do know about the Ottoman court education and lala, tutor for princes. There are sources stating that Murad II’s, Mehmed’s father, court in Edirne was a multi-cultural environment with Jewish physicians, non-Muslim translators. In addition to these, we know that Çandarlı Halil Paşa, later his grand vizier was Mehmed’s lala. Furthermore, there is a notebook, claimed to be Mehmed’s belonging, and it contains portrait drawings, Greek alphabet, Arabic letters. It gives us a significant hint to see what kind of literary training Mehmed could have received.

6- Sultan Mehmet and later Sultans used allied vassal states such as Serbians and Bulgarians in great numbers and in some battles they were crucial in the outcome. Do we know to what extent these Christian allies were used in the siege of the city and would they also be ‘rewarded’ with the 3 day post-capture plunder like the Moslem soldiers?

I do not know about the non-Muslim soldiers unfortunately.

7- Could we argue the tolerance and respect Sultan Mehmet gave to the vanquished Greek (Rum) population was ‘maxed’ to assert his say over both the Ulema and Turcoman lords who probably had a diametrically opposing view of how the Empire should evolve?

Mehmed clearly wanted to lead a universal multi-cultural empire and his capital must have reflected that. Therefore, he moved the Armenian Patriarchy to Constantinople from Bursa, he moved Turks from Aksaray-Karaman area and Jews from Thessaloniki. However, the conquest also a turning point in the evolution of the empire. We see that devshirme, converts, were more dominant after Çandarlı Halil Paşa’s execution. We can observe the change/evolution also in literary works. For example, with the 2nd half of the 15th century, the Ottomans change their literary rhetoric they produce history dealing chronicles in a more professional way. And yes, the anonymous legends dated in the last decade of the 15th century highly criticize Mehmed II’s universal empire ambition.

8- Sultan Mehmet clearly gave orders to his marauding troops to save Hagia Sophia from the general sac. Do we know if its library was also pretty unharmed and do we know what happened to that collection and can we trace some items still today?

Sources indicate that many books from the Imperial Court were also sacked and sold out. We can understand that Mehmed did his best to preserve books and collections. However, his library was dispersed during his son Beyazid II’s reign. We can trace some of them thanks to seals on them. They are sent away to different libraries out of the court while some remained in the Topkapı libraries.

9- Sultan Mehmet also was into knowledge and books and his collection was dispersed by his son Beyazit II with whom he had a difficult relationship. Can we argue that Beyazit II tried to ‘row back’ from his father’s more ‘universal’ empire notion and do you think again there would have been ‘counter friction’ from Ottoman elites who saw the benefits from a more open society?

It should not be wrong to argue that Beyazid II rowed back his father’s goals. We see him as a more pious and not a warrior character as he conquered only two castles connecting Ottoman Wallachia to Crimea. As a new Sultan to establish and sustain his authority, he had to prove his power by winning a battle. Besides that, he also had to deal with his brother Cem who claimed the throne and kept in custody in Europe. And it is argued that the high state officers favoured Beyazid, who would bring stability, while the Jannisary army favoured Cem who would go after his father’s incomplete conquests. At the end, the messenger to Cem was killed, so Beyazid arrived the capital first and claimed the throne.

10- Sultan Mehmet’s life was cut short under mysterious circumstances and his offensive in Otranto in South Italy went nowhere as his son recalled the troops and executed the commander. Do you think Sultan Mehmet was in the early stages of completing his dream of conquering Rome in due course and so completing his mission of recreating the Roman Empire and him as the Emperor but in Islamic colours?

We do not certainly know that if he was going to Italy, but it would not be surprising as we count that the Ottomans were already holding Otranto and Mehmed died around Gebze where the fleet was anchored. As the Caesar of the Nova Roma or 2nd Rome, he would have gone for the first one as well. This is very likely, also his cultural relations with Italians indicate that he was also interested in Italy.

11- After Sultan Mehmet it appears the Ottomans had very little interest in this legacy (apart from the building of Hagia Sophia) and its learning and writings seem to have been discarded for foreign buyers ‘on the cheap’. Do you think this could be seen as one of Sultan Mehmet’s failings in that he couldn’t leave a legacy of that vision of ‘learning from the other’?

I do not think the Ottomans lost their interest in the Roman heritage. Greek was kept as international correspondence language until the mid-16th century, there are Greek firmans in Venice with the tuğra (signature) of Beyazid II. Even Abdülhamid II (r. 1876-1909) is mentioned together with the word “Byzantine” on a Latin Catholic church in Beyoğlu.

12- Byzantines seem to have also a tendency of ‘learning from the other’, so translating back to Greek many of the ‘lost’ classical works held in the great libraries in Arabia before the Mongol onslaught. Do you think this open dialogue leading to knowledge flow helped Byzantium survive with their wits and diplomacy, when weak, for over a millennium in a very turbulent part of the world?

I do not know to what extent their knowledge in antiquity helped them with their diplomacy. However, we can consider growing Turkish power on the edge Europe was worrying Christian Europeans while many Orthodox Greeks would prefer Turkish rule to allying with Catholics after the 1204 Crusader invasion to the Byzantine lands and Constantinople. We can probably even argue that the invasion from Catholic side made Muslims and Orthodoxs allies in the 13th century. However, fall of Constantinople into Turkish hands would be regarded as a catastrophe in Europe, so European powers would prefer a weak Roman Empire, at least being Christian, to the Turks who were already controlling the Balkans, the edge of Europe.

Questions by Craig Encer, November 2020