Buket Altinoba hybrid lecture: ‘The Istanbul Academy of fine arts in the late Ottoman Empire. Between Modernism, Nation-building, and Cultural Transfer’, 10 January 2023 - flyer:

Buket Altinoba hybrid lecture: ‘The Istanbul Academy of fine arts in the late Ottoman Empire. Between Modernism, Nation-building, and Cultural Transfer’, 10 January 2023 - flyer:

1- Can you share how you first became interested in researching the Istanbul Academy of Fine Arts?
My interest in researching the Istanbul Academy of Fine Arts arises from its intriguing position at the intersection of global and local dynamics, a concept often referred to as ‘glocal’. Exploring this institution from such a perspective promises insights. Delving into its impact on the local Istanbul art scene, its cultural contributions, and its connections to the global art community reveals a complex web of influences and interactions. Ultimately, my drive to study the Istanbul Academy of Fine Arts and the training of artistic practice, as with any institution, stems from personal curiosity, academic interest and cultural engagement. In particular, there’s a significant gap in European art historical research on this subject.
2- What were the main sources you used in researching the Academy and Osman Hamdi Bey?
My research approach aimed to delve into the theory and practice of art in the late Ottoman state and contemporary Turkey through a nuanced exploration from a variety of perspectives. This was achieved by juxtaposing oral and written debates on historical and contemporary events. Primary sources included literature in its original language from the archives of the MSGSÜ, supplemented by insightful discussions with experts in the fields of art, museology and architecture. These findings were then compared and evaluated with European and US viewpoints, offering an alternative perspective from an ‘Oriental’ point of view to challenge prevailing norms and terminologies. In addition, the empirical data collected and tabulated facilitated an initial inventory of artists and cultural practitioners from the region, shedding light on previously overlooked dynamics and cultural dialogues. Through this approach, a discursive postcolonial critique emerged, broadening the scope of the ‘Orientalism debate’ to include cross-cultural enquiry and amplifying the voices of both sides of the discourse.
3- As a very elite movement was there any discontent among the elites or artistic community involved about a movement so heavily influenced by Europe?
As a movement influenced by European art and culture, the emergence of a highly elite artistic movement in the late Ottoman Empire since the second half of the nineteenth century did indeed cause some discontent among certain segments of the Ottoman cultural and artistic community. This sense of disenchantment may also have resulted from inequalities in access to resources, opportunities and recognition within the burgeoning art scene. While some welcomed the infusion of European aesthetics and techniques as a means of modernisation and cultural progress, others met these changes with skepticism or outright opposition, particularly traditionalists who feared a dilution of Ottoman cultural identity in the face of Westernisation. Among the discontented were traditionalists who feared the erosion of Ottoman cultural identity and authenticity in the face of Westernisation. They saw the adoption of European styles and themes as a threat to the preservation of the Ottoman artistic heritage. In architecture, for example, the curriculum of the Academy of Fine Arts, initially modelled on the French École-des-Beaux-Arts, emphasised classical drawing and the study of Greco-Roman styles, before gradually incorporating classical Ottoman architecture as a result of student rebellion. A new educational approach aimed to combine traditional and academic elements, giving rise to the “First National Architectural Movement” (1908-1930), characterised by buildings that combined Ottoman and Seljuk features with neoclassical elements such as symmetrical facades and domed towers decorated with ceramic tiles and stained glass. Dissatisfaction with European influence led to a second movement in the 1940s, which was rooted in indigenous building traditions but adopted a modernist style. Figures such as the architect Sedat Hakkı Eldem played a key role in both movements, advocating a national architectural style to preserve Ottoman cultural identity in the face of Westernisation. These protagonists engaged in a discourse about cultural identity and perception within a nationalist framework, reflecting broader debates about modernisation and societal transformation. Overall, while the elite European-influenced movement gained recognition and prestige, it also provoked complex reactions and tensions within Ottoman society, reflecting wider debates about cultural identity and societal change during this period.
4- How did this artistic movement change and develop with the dawning of the Turkish Republic?
With the advent of the Turkish Republic, Turkey’s artistic movement underwent significant transformations and advancements. Led by Mustafa Kemal Atatürk, the Republic embarked on a comprehensive program of social and cultural reforms known as the “Turkish Modernisation Project”. This initiative aimed to modernise and secularise Turkish society, including its artistic landscape, by embracing Western ideals while emphasising national identity. A key aspect of this transformation was the promotion of a new artistic language that fused Western techniques with Turkish themes and motifs, known as Turkish Nationalism in Art. This approach aimed to cultivate a distinctly Turkish style that celebrated the nation's cultural heritage while aligning with modern artistic trends. The Republic of Turkey also played a proactive role in promoting the arts, establishing institutions such as academies, museums and galleries to support and promote Turkish artists. Art education was also reformed to reflect the new cultural direction of the Republic, with an emphasis on teaching Western artistic principles alongside Turkish cultural history. During the early republican period, certain aspects of the educational support for artists that had begun in the 19th century were continued, laying the foundations for a modern education sector in Turkey. These included specialised training with diplomas, the establishment of specific educational institutions and the promotion of scientific research projects. With the aim of building a nation and a genuinely Turkish culture, Atatürk assigned the arts a crucial role in identity formation. The prototype of the intellectual artist that emerged on the eve of the republic established itself in a tradition protected by the state, which, until the post-war period, included sending graduates of the Art Academy to Europe on scholarships. Furthermore, state patronage led to the commissioning of public artworks and monuments that celebrated Turkish national identity and historical figures, contributing to the visual landscape of the new republic. Overall, the artistic movement in Turkey during the early years of the Republic was characterised by a mixture of Western modernism and Turkish nationalism, reflecting the wider cultural and political changes taking place in the country.
5- Osman Hamdi bey in his time in Paris trained under French orientalist painters Jean-Léon Gérôme and Gustave Boulanger. Osman Hamdi clearly had a style that then evolved with his own outlook. How would you describe his ‘Orientalism’ as depicted in the themes of his paintings?
Osman Hamdi Bey’s ‘Orientalism’ in his paintings is characterised by a unique blend of Western artistic training and a deep-rooted appreciation of the Ottoman heritage. Influenced by his time in Paris and his training with French Orientalist painters such as Jean-Léon Gérôme and Gustave Boulanger, Osman Hamdi Bey developed a distinctive style that went beyond mere imitation of his mentors. In his artworks, Osman Hamdi Bey explored themes that reflected his fascination with classical history, Ottoman culture and society. He often depicted scenes from everyday life in the Ottoman Empire, capturing the essence of Ottoman traditions, customs and rituals. His compositions were meticulously detailed, showing a keen observation of his surroundings and a mastery of light, colour and texture. Unlike some of his European contemporaries who portrayed their versions of the Near East through a lens of exoticism and romanticism, Osman Hamdi Bey approached his subjects with a sense of authenticity. His paintings revealed a deep understanding and empathy for the people and landscapes he depicted, eschewing Orientalist stereotypes in favour of nuanced depictions that celebrated the richness and diversity of Ottoman life. Moreover, Osman Hamdi Bey’s paintings went beyond picturesque scenes or idealized representations of how Europeans imagined the Orient. As the director of the Museum of Archaeology and Fine Arts, he explored artifacts unearthed during his surveys and presented them in the museum, only to paint them later in his art. He also tackled more complex and thought-provoking themes, such as the intersection of tradition and modernity, the impact of colonialism, and the challenges facing Ottoman society during a period of transition. Overall, Osman Hamdi Bey’s way of presenting his culture can be characterised as a nuanced and introspective exploration of Ottoman identity, informed by his experiences in both the East and the West as well as his professions. His paintings offer viewers a window into the complexities of Ottoman life and history, inviting reflection and dialogue on issues that remain relevant today.
6- The first Ottoman painters came from military backgrounds such as ‘Ahmet Seker Pasha’ and ‘Suleyman Seyyid’. Also in the 1860s the Young Ottomans were also founded in the same changing political climate, but this time coming chiefly from the imperial medical school. Do you think this was partly a symptom of a restricted intellectual environment and so these movers came from established national institutions, but clearly holding a somewhat rebellious streak?
The emergence of Ottoman painters with military backgrounds, such as Ahmet Şeker Pasha and Süleyman Seyyid, and the founding of the Young Ottomans in the 1860s, mainly from the imperial medical school, suggest a multifaceted response to the socio-political climate of the time. It’s plausible to see this phenomenon partly as a reflection of the restricted intellectual environment that prevailed in the Ottoman Empire at the time. Established national institutions, such as the military and medical schools, provided avenues for individuals to pursue intellectual and creative endeavours within the confines of existing social and political structures. It’s important to recognise, however, that these movers and shakers were not merely conformists, but had a rebellious streak that challenged orthodoxies and advocated reform. The military in particular provided a platform for individuals such as Ahmet Şeker Pasha and Süleyman Seyyid to express dissent and innovation, albeit within certain constraints. Military life often fostered a sense of camaraderie and discipline, while exposing individuals to different experiences and perspectives that could fuel intellectual curiosity and rebellious tendencies. Similarly, the imperial medical school served as a hub for aspiring intellectuals who sought to engage with contemporary issues and contribute to the reform efforts of the time. The Young Ottomans, comprising mostly students and graduates of the medical school, embodied a spirit of intellectual inquiry and activism, challenging traditional norms and advocating for constitutionalism and modernization. In essence, the emergence of Ottoman painters and intellectuals from established national institutions reflects both the restrictive nature of the intellectual environment and the resilience of individuals who sought to push boundaries and effect change. Their rebellious streaks were not only a response to limitations but also a testament to their courage, vision, and commitment to reforming Ottoman society amidst challenging circumstances.
7- What role did the Academy play in forming the modern Turkish cultural identity?
The Academy of Fine Arts has played a pivotal role in shaping modern Turkish cultural identity through its multiple contributions to artistic education, cultural production, and the formation of national identity. Firstly, the Academy served as a cornerstone of artistic education, providing aspiring artists with rigorous training in various disciplines such as painting, sculpture, architecture and applied arts. By nurturing artistic talent and encouraging creativity, the Academy played a crucial role in cultivating a generation of Turkish artists who would go on to shape the nation’s visual culture. The Academy also acted as a hub for artistic innovation and experimentation, facilitating the exchange of ideas and influences between artists and intellectuals. This environment of intellectual ferment and artistic exchange contributed to the development of a distinctly Turkish artistic language that synthesised local traditions with global artistic trends. The Academy also played a central role in the institutionalisation and professionalisation of the arts in Turkey. Through its exhibitions, publications and public outreach programmes, the Academy helped to raise the status of the arts in Turkish society and promote a greater appreciation of artistic expression. In addition to its role in artistic education and production, the Academy also played a symbolic role in the construction of modern Turkish cultural identity. As an institution founded in the early years of the Turkish Republic, the Academy embodied the ideals of modernisation, secularism and national identity promoted by Mustafa Kemal Atatürk and his associates. Its emphasis on artistic excellence, innovation and cultural heritage reflected the broader aspirations of the Republic to forge a modern, progressive and culturally vibrant nation. In summary, the Academy of Fine Arts has played a multifaceted role in shaping modern Turkish cultural identity by nurturing artistic talent, promoting artistic innovation, institutionalising the arts and embodying the ideals of the Turkish Republic. Its contributions to artistic education, cultural production and the formation of national identity continue to shape Turkey’s cultural landscape to this day.
8- Was Pera district the epicentre of this artistic awakening in the second half of the 19th century? Do we have a good handle on the various sponsors and buyers of this artistic out-put in terms of roughly what proportion ended in the households of Ottoman aristocracy, what ended up in national collections and what ended up abroad through visitors?
The Pera district undoubtedly played an important role as a centre of artistic activity and cultural exchange in Istanbul during the second half of the 19th century. However, it would be too simplistic to describe it as the sole epicentre of the artistic awakening of the period; for example, Kadiköy and Üsküdar, on the Asian side of the city, were known for their workshops, studios and galleries where various forms of art, including calligraphy, ceramics and painting, flourished. It had its own vibrant cultural scene and contributed to the artistic landscape of Constantinople. In the second half of the 19th century, Istanbul’s Pera district became a vibrant centre of artistic exchange, home to prestigious schools, galleries and cultural spaces. However, the artistic awakening of this period extended beyond Pera, Galata and Tophane encompassing various regions and communities within the Ottoman Empire. Artistic production flourished in Istanbul and beyond, reflecting different styles, genres and traditions. Patronage for artworks came from a broad spectrum, including Ottoman elites, government officials, religious institutions and foreign collectors, shaping a complex artistic landscape influenced by urbanisation, globalisation and cultural exchange. While Pera stood out as an important centre, the artistic renaissance of the period was a multifaceted phenomenon that extended throughout the Ottoman Empire and beyond.
9- Was access to Academy education in any way restricted by gender, religion or ethnicity? Or was it simply a socio-economic barrier to entry?
Access to art academy education in the Ottoman Empire was primarily restricted by socio-economic factors rather than gender, religion or ethnicity. However, it’s important to recognise that the dynamics of access to education varied over time and across different regions of the empire. During the late Ottoman period, particularly in the 19th century, the Ottoman state undertook a series of reforms aimed at modernising and secularising the education system. As part of these reforms, efforts were made to extend access to education, including art education, to a wider section of the population. For example, we see that in the last years of the Ottoman reign when - at latest - in the aftermath of the second constitution early attempts for democracy were made, women played a symbolical role in terms of nationalism, modern society, and higher education: toward the end of the Ottoman Empire and after the reform movements of the “Tanzimat” era during 19th century, the daughters of the aristocracy were encouraged to pursue an education in art, literature, and music. Against this backdrop, and amidst the burgeoning liberation movements, the Istanbul Women’s University was inaugurated in February 1914, offering classes four days a week in the afternoons at the Zeynep Hanım Mansion, the former site of today’s Istanbul University. The same year, in October 1914 the Academy of Fine Arts began to admit female students in a separate building from the male students.
10- Yervant Voskan was the first known sculptor in modern Turkish sculpture history and as the first sculpture teacher at the Sanay-i Nefise. He began teaching sculpture in the academy on 1883 and was the only professor of sculpture in the Ottoman Empire. The first time period was spent looking for students to teach as it was difficult at the time to find students who wanted to study sculpture. Do you think this point to a lack of trickling down of the Ottoman artistic enlightenment and the very narrow band of the strata being able to afford that education?
Indeed, the challenges that Yervant Oskan faced in finding students to teach sculpture at the Sanay-i Nefise Academy in the late nineteenth century point to several factors that may have limited the democratisation of artistic education in the Ottoman Empire during this period. First, the scarcity of students interested in studying sculpture may reflect broader societal attitudes towards art and artistic education at the time. While the late Ottoman period witnessed significant efforts to modernise and secularise the education system, traditional attitudes towards education, particularly in the arts, may have persisted among certain segments of society. The pursuit of artistic education may have been perceived as non-essential or secondary to more practical or vocational pursuits, resulting in a limited pool of potential students for sculpture classes. In addition, socio-economic factors are likely to have played a significant role in limiting access to artistic education. While the Fine Arts Academy aimed to provide education to a wider segment of the population, the state funded the art education and travel expenses abroad. In addition, the lack of a well-established tradition of sculpture in the Ottoman Empire may have contributed to the difficulty in finding students interested in studying this particular art form or religious restrictions. Unlike painting or calligraphy, which had deep-rooted traditions in Ottoman artistic practice, sculpture may have been perceived as a less familiar or prestigious art form, further reducing its appeal to potential students. Overall, the challenges Yervant Oskan faced in finding students to teach sculpture at the Sanay-i Nefise Academy reflect broader socio-economic and cultural factors that may have limited the democratisation of artistic education in the late Ottoman Empire. While efforts were made to widen access to artistic training, significant barriers remained, resulting in a narrow range of individuals who could afford and pursue such training.
11- Finally – what’s next for you research?
Thank you for your interest in my research. My focus remains on exploring the intersections of art, culture and society, with a keen interest in understanding the dynamics of artistic exchange and the impact of technology on global artistic production since the industrial age. However, central to this exploration is the mechanical process of sculptural reproduction, which plays a pivotal role within artistic practice and machine culture. This convergence of art and technology, rooted in the Renaissance concept of the ‘uomo universale’, experienced a resurgence in the nineteenth century as sculptors embraced earlier pointing techniques. Collaborations between artists and engineers spurred mass production, revolutionising workshops and artistic norms. Through this study, I aim to explore these intersections and their ongoing evolution.