Dr Ellinor Morack online presentation: ‘Dispossession, confiscation, appropriation: property rights of minorities in modern Turkey’, 25 June 2024 - flyer:
1- Did the “abandoned property” (emval-i metruke) law introduced in 1915 deal purely with the legal route of dealing with real estate whose owners were not present and excluded any reference to how these properties became abandoned suddenly and by who? To your knowledge was this law ever used by properties formerly owned by Muslim families?
As far as I know, the law was never used for property owned by Muslims. It does not speak of Armenians, but of “people deported/moved to other places (ahar mahallere nakledilen eşhas) - and Muslims were not deported at that time. An earlier regulation issued in June 1915 (which, unlike the “liquidation law” of September 1915, was not published), openly speaks of the fact that the people in question were Armenians. But publicly, this was not admitted. During the 1921-22 debate surrounding the follow-up bill, several (Muslim) deputies in the Turkish National Assembly voiced their concern that they might be next. Some opposed the bill arguing that such a stipulation could be used against all of them, at any time in the future - But I have never come across such a case.
For those Muslims who were treated as traitors after 1923 and not allowed to return to Turkey, the famous 150likler, there was a special law stripping them of both their citizenship and their property rights, and their right to inherit (in 1927, law no. 1064), and another one for the abolition of the caliphate, which also stipulated that property owned by the sultanic family would be liquidated, issued in 1924 (no. 431).
2- Families such as the Kasabians you referred to who formerly owned the properties that later became the Presidential residence of Çankaya Köşkü found sanctuary in Istanbul that was exempt from the deportation order and lived in that city till 1957 when the grandson emigrated to Canada. Did any of these internally displaced Armenians open court cases to seek compensation or restitution as far as you know in the later decades?
Quite a few Armenians who survived did so either by fleeing to Istanbul or Izmir or, having survived in Anatolia or in present-day Syria, moved to Istanbul in republican times. I have never heard of anyone opening a court case and have not seen such a case reported on in republican-era newspapers. But, as court records are not open for research, there might have been such cases that are simply not known.
3- Both Ottoman law and Turkish Republican law explicitly protects the property rights of all of its citizens without distinction to their ethnicity. So did the early Turkish republic use the argument that earlier Ottoman citizenship of Armenians or other minorities couldn’t be transferred to a Republican one if they were resident abroad by the time of the establishment of the Republic and therefore show that they were still following the letter of the law?
Expropriation without compensation was and is illegal, both in Ottoman imperial and in republican times. Citizenship was never a requirement for the protection of property rights. While the constitutions of 1878 and 1924 speak of equal rights for all CITIZENS, the articles discussing property rights do not mention ethnicity or citizenship at all: “everybody” (herkes) is secure in the enjoyment of property rights (Art. 21 of the 1878 constitution). This is a result of a liberal property regime, in which foreigners, too, can own property, but do generally not enjoy other rights such as suffrage etc.
The republican governments did indeed argue that people who had left Turkey or Istanbul (and had done so without Turkish passports, especially in 1922, when the Turkish army came close to marching on occupied Istanbul) could not return, but this was mainly a phenomenon of post-war Istanbul and mostly connected to the issue of “établi” status in accordance with the Greek-Turkish population exchange. As I say above, for protection of property, it ought not to have been relevant (legally speaking).
4- Conversion of Byzantine churches to mosques was a tradition right from 1453 when Sultan Mehmet converted the Hagia Sophia. So could you argue that the Ottoman system was inherently prejudicial to non-Moslem minorities and till Tanzimat where all Christian / Jewish real estate was fair game for confiscation and this memory never truly died out and was a useful template by 1915?
No. It is true that the Ottomans, during their conquests, generally converted (prominent) churches to mosques. However, this is a matter of mostly symbolic importance, and it was not continued in the centuries after the conquest. (We actually have evidence for the widespread practice of Muslims and Christians using sacred spaces together. In some places, Christians were allowed to hold Easter mass in mosques that had once been churches). Churches and synagogues could be built and were built in Ottoman times, and they were generally secure. The same goes for private property of Christians and Jews, which was comparatively much safer than Jewish property in Europe. There were incidents of rioting and pogroms (discussed by Marc Baer, for example), but on a much much lower scale and frequency than in early modern Europe. Up to the mid-19th century, the Ottoman Empire was a refuge for ethnic and religious minorities and political refugees from Europe, and not a country that people fled from. This was reversed only from the 1890s onward.
5- The Lausanne treaty signed in 1924 guaranteed property rights of all citizens of Turkey but do you think the early Republican Turkey chose to interpreted that in its own manner by stating that anything that happened before that signing including all property transfers were not covered by the law and therefore there could be no question of restitution?
This is how they argued. But I think they avoided the actual question, namely that of the constitutionality or legality of the liquidation of Christian property. It was, effectively, dispossession, which was and is illegal in Turkey. Both the Ottoman and the Turkish constitution state that expropriation may only be performed in the name of the public good and against prior compensation. Neither condition was fulfilled here. Also, even if we did argue that they seized Armenian property under conditions of war (i.e., for the public good), then why no return it after the war? I think the explanation is an implicit assumption that discrimination along ethno-religious lines serves the public good, which is, again implicitly, understood as the public good of the Turkish nation.
6- In 1963 the newly formed Constitutional Court of Turkey issued a verdict on the constitutionality of the ‘liquidation law’ of 1915 and the ‘abandoned property law’ of 1922-4. A majority verdict of 8 to 6 by the judges deemed those laws constitutional but clearly there was an internal division in that interpretation. Two dissenting opinions were published which presumably until then would have been impossible. One of minority opinion writing, the judge Akçaoğlu, points to the Court not answering the right questions but looking through a narrow lens. Do you think that was a safe route out for the court in an impossible situation as that could have led to a seismic shift in looking at its murky past?
I think that the establishment of a constitutional court in itself was an absolutely important milestone in Turkish history, and this verdict (and the minority verdicts) are part of that development. There were precedents of such protests being recorded- for instance, in 1915 in the Ottoman senate, where senator Ahmet Rıza criticized the deportation and dispossession of Ottoman Armenians - or the few ulema deputies who opposed the “abandoned property” law in the National Assembly in 1922, arguing that it violated Islamic law (I discuss that debate in detail in my book). Many other objections and instances of criticism by Muslims and Turks probably went unrecorded.
As for the “seismic shift”, I don’t know, it is always difficult to make contra-factual arguments... If a majority had voted that the laws were unconstitutional and that they could no longer be applied, yes, maybe the whole issue would have started to be treated differently in Turkey. But maybe, in that case, they would just have been sacked, or a sufficient number of judges would have been bullied into changing their minds. But there was no such majority, and this is telling: if you look closely enough, you see that all three verdicts argue that, in one way or another, what had happened was fine. Yes, the first verdict is criticized for not considering the question of constitutionality, but actually, it is the only one admitting that there was something wrong with the laws in the first place.
7- In 1964 the Turkish government forced all Greek passport holders and their dependants living in Istanbul to leave the country at short notice. How was the ‘abandoned property’ in that case dealt by the Turkish Government then and later?
I have not worked on that. I only know all those neighbourhoods of historical Istanbul (Tarlabaşı, for instance) where, at least by the early 2000s, there were many, many buildings with unresolved ownership issues- most of them were empty and slowly rotting away. How exactly the legal background to that was is something I simply don’t know.
8- There are still standing iconic Armenian properties such as the Aghtamar island church in Lake Van. The church was restored by the Turkish state with its own money and opened as a museum in 2007 yet with the name ‘Turkified’ as Akdamar (white vein) and religious services are allowed only once a year. Do you think this marks the limits of official Turkish recognition and allowance of Armenian culture to reflourish in Turkey or a gradual softening of its stance as those minority communities are no longer seen as a threat to national cohesion?
There are more (and more positive) examples, such as the Surp Giragos cathedral in Diyarbekir, which was rebuilt with donations and re-sacrated, it currently functions as a church. That would have been unthinkable up to the late 1990s. (The cathedral was confiscated by the state in 2016, along with a major part of the historical inner city after the fighting with the PKK, but given back in 2017, later serving as a place of refuge for earthquake victims in February 2023). Several Orthodox churches outside of Istanbul have been renovated as well, but do not function as churches anymore.
But in principle, yes, there is a tendency to regard the remaining non-Muslim minorities as relatively harmless, and to treat churches etc. as museums whose restauration can be presented as exemplary cases of cultural heritage preservation- and for the boosting of cultural heritage tourism. This is also happening with Syriac houses in and around Mardin, Özlem Zerrin Biner discusses this in her book “States of Dispossession”.
Whether cases such as the Aghtamar church (renovation, but for museum purposes only) mark the limits of Turkish policy towards the Armenians- I don’t know. There is a saying in Turkish: in Turkey, anything is possible. Either positive or negative: really anything.
Questions by Craig Encer, July 2024
Bibliography:
Biner, Zerrin Özlem. States of Dispossession: Violence and Precarious Coexistence in Southeast Turkey. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2020.Kaiser, Hilmar. ‘1915-1916 Ermeni Soykırımı Sırasında Ermeni Mülkleri, Osmanlı Hukuku ve Milliyet Politikaları’. In İmparatorluktan Cumhuriyete Türkiye’de Etnik Çatışma, edited by Erik Jan Zürcher, 123–56. Istanbul: İletişim, 2005.
Kezer, Zeynep. ‘Of Forgotten People and Forgotten Places: Nation-Building and the Dismantling of Ankara’s Non-Muslim Landscapes’. In On Location: Heritage Cities and Sites, edited by D. Fairchild Ruggles. New York: Springer, 2012, 169–191.
Kurt, Ümit. The Armenians of Aintab: The Economics of Genocide in an Ottoman Province. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press, 2021.
Onaran, Nevzat. Emvâl-i Metrûke Olayı: Osmanlı’da ve Cumhuriyette Ermeni ve Rum Mallarının Türkleştirilmesi. Istanbul: Belge, 2010.
Öz, İlkay. Mülksüzleştirme ve Türkleştirme: Edirne Örneği. İstanbul: İletişim Yayınları, 2020.