Vassilis Colonas online presentation: ‘Smyrna (1870-1922), City and Architecture, The contribution of the Greeks’, 12 November 2024 - flyer:
1- Your book ‘Smyrna (1870-1922) city and architecture: the contribution of the Greeks’, covers a period from 1870 but not from the Tanzimat of 1856 (promising full legal equality for citizens of all religions) when churches were allowed to have bell towers so there was a rush in their reconstruction. Is there a reason why you chose 1870 as the starting point of your focus?
I chose it because the construction of the new sea front was a major project that largely affected the image of the city as a whole…
2- The fire insurance map of Charles Goad of London done of Smyrna in 1905 clearly is a very valuable resource for your investigation as it shows in the areas covered a lot of secondary information such as material used in buildings and assigned names of companies / individuals associated with various plots. For areas not covered by this map series such as Konak / Kemeralti, did you have alternative sources of information to go on?
No, I didn’t have…
3- You recorded around 20 Greek architects in Smyrna (do you make a distinction between Greek citizens and Ottoman Greeks here?) and only 2 French and no other ethnicity. Do you think this is a reflection of the good quality of foundation education given to Greek pupils in the city before 1922 and their ability to freely move to European cities to specialise in architectural studies as presumably there was no such institution in the Ottoman Empire?
I said that of the 20, there was one French and one Turkish architects and I don't know the official citizenship of all of them. Most likely those who came from Greece looking for work may have kept their Greek citizenship. As far as education is concerned, no, I don't think that was the reason. There were such institutions in Constantinople but I have no information about graduates of these schools originated from Smyrna. The majority of the Greek architects who were active in Izmir came from Greece seeking work in a prosperous metropolis under reconstruction. I know that three of them were graduates of schools in Athens, Paris and Ingolstadt. There were also the so-called caliphs, the empirical architects. In Smyrna, because a large part of the population was Greek, it was natural that they were preferred by them.
4- Were you able to access the private / family archives of any of these Greek architects? Did any continue their profession (perhaps through their offspring as well) later in Greece or elsewhere post 1922?
On Smyrna, nothing at all.
5- Was there much if any variation on these architects’ styles, perhaps subtly reflecting their education in different ecoles of Europe so Parisian versus Berlin perhaps? Can we talk of a ‘Smyrna’ style of architecture or was it strictly following international trends of the time?
There was a specific Smyrna house type, The “Sakiz ada ev” type -but not a style- dictated mostly by building regulations.
6- Just how hard or easy is it to extract information and drawings in the Ottoman archives? You were able to access numerous privately / community commissioned building drawings but hardly none that was civic. Is this a reflection of these state sanctioned buildings being directed by the Sultan effectively and so those archives, if they exist, are not part of the Prime-ministerial main repository of archives?
No, we don't know. They may be classified according to different criteria, for example by ministry ( ? ) or they may not have been explored yet.
7- I understand that in Ottoman / Turkish records all title deed and building permit records are inaccessible to researchers, but is there any collection of such records held by descendants and perhaps now accessible in refugee associations in Greece?
Nothing found concerning Smyrna.
8- You have studied Greek architects in other parts of the late Ottoman Empire as well. Is it a similar case of Tanzimat offering that field of opportunity and free ability to operate leading to a flourishing of this trade in numbers far exceeding other ethnicities in the Empire? Were these always operating solely in their own cities / regions?
My researches were only on Greek architects and owners, in port cities of the Ottoman Empire on Aegean or Black sea shores.
9- Clearly in Smyrna there are / were buildings whose architect is established and those where the person is suspected or not known at all. Before your study was there a database for you to refer or did you start from zero? Is there more work to be done?
I had at my disposal only the professional guide books of Smyrna and the writings of local history authors for some of the well known buildings of the public or private sector.
10- You are advanced in your study of Greek architects of Bursa and planning a future publication on this subject. How much remains of the old city in Bursa with that Greek trace?
It should be a mistake , I’ve never conducted a research on Bursa. I only made a reference to some state buildings of Bursa following the same models adapted for similar buildings in other cities of the Ottoman Empire.
11- Smyrna got its modern quay rather late (1875) for a busy port compared to other trade hubs across the Eastern Mediterranean and this presumably cramped the space along that shorefront with former plots going out towards the sea with the new infill but not being able to widen as their neighbours also presumably valued their own precious plot. Do you see architectural adaptations to overcome this constrained space in the way the various pleasure establishments etc. were built here?
I am not sure that I’ve quite understood what you mean, I think in my book is clearly explained the way the infill gradually took place . In every case this had little to do with architecture and was more conforme to building regulations and different ownerships how they appear in the land registry.