Vera Constantini hybrid lecture: ‘Aubrey Herbert and the “Other” Britain: A Turkish Perspective’, 10 December 2024 - flyer: - slides:
1- This historical character of Audrey Herbert clearly captured your attention though it is not in your main research area of Ottoman – Venetian – Bosnian relations. So was this an accidental discovery for you while researching British archives of the period of WWI on different topics?
I believe that archival encounters are never completely accidental. Any research on early 20th century inevitably leads to considering a large amount of sources that mention a wide spectrum of people out of different reasons. Why does a historical character capture your attention more than another? When we approach a new topic and with that topic in mind we start to investigate the primary sources, our intention is already partially defining the outcome. We are historically determined human beings and as such we have principles and opinions that may lead us to look in the past for the causes of what in the present seems most obscure and controversial. There is little doubt that nowadays one of the most controversial issues is the political situation in the Middle East. Consequently, I am not surprised to acknowledge that, while considering British foreign policy in the years before and after WW1, I was attracted by one of the few dissenting voices. Aubrey Herbert demonstrates that dissent existed, that someone was aware of the error and danger of the path that Great Britain, the leading economy of the world, was about to take.
This unusual foray into the contemporary age was motivated by my desire to understand the reasons for the cultural weakness of Oriental studies in Italy. The hypothesis underlying my research is that this weakness is connected to the unmaking of Italy’s Eastern policy in the aftermath of WW1. In this unmaking, the British government, but also the French, had a major responsibility. To reconstruct this phenomenon, I decided to start looking at British sources. And there stood Aubrey Herbert, staring at me from old pictures with his open, almost astonished gaze, speaking to posterity with words of detached, crystal-cut honesty.
2- You stated that the ‘Turkish perspective’ is the only antidote to the ‘Orientalist approach’. Do you think this ‘Western gaze’ to the history of Ottoman / Turkish historic analysis is still prevalent in contemporary historical assessments and do you consider this to be unhelpful in framing even Westerners like Audrey Herbert who operated in that geography?
Although significant steps have been taken in the framework of the discipline itself, still a lot needs to be done to integrate Ottoman Studies within mainstream historiography. A historian of the Republic of Venice who works on Ottoman sources is still considered an “Ottomanist” more than a historian. There is a general lack of legitimacy, connected to a well-supported ideological prejudice. Furthermore, in many countries the path to become a fully acknowledged Ottoman historian goes through a fully Orientalist education, that inevitably shapes the approach of future scholars.
The history of the Ottoman Empire is an exceptional training ground for critical thinking. On one side, it represents the memory and the legacy of the many peoples involved in its long duration. On the other side, it provides an alternative perspective for the understanding of the history of other countries too. To his contemporaries, Aubrey Herbert appeared as a slightly borderline personality, due to his handicap and to the peculiarity of his family tradition. Unaware of his intuitions, they thought that even his Turcophilia was just another awkward detail of the picture. In reality, his semi-blindness didn’t prevent him to see, better than the vast majority of his peers, the dangerous future outcome of Great Britain’s unfair treatment of the Ottoman leading class and institutions. How did he develop such an unconventional “sight”? I think he was used to being spoken a different language since the earliest childhood. With “different language” I do not mean necessarily a foreign language. Pictures portray his father’s loving attitude, confirmed by his exceptional efforts to ease Aubrey’s sight problems. His mother entertained a close and emotionally vibrant correspondence with him throughout his life. Providing emotional support to children, especially if they had some kind of handicap, was not a common feature in those times. I believe that such an emotionally nourished childhood and the awareness of his own otherness provided Aubrey Herbert with an exceptional intellectual clarity and capacity of critical thinking. Since his vision was not clouded by the prejudices of the time, he was able to conduct his existence according to principles of rightfulness that could not but separate him irremediably from the policy of the British governments.
3- Audrey Herbert was a parliamentarian from 1911 till his death in 1923, a Conservative party member of parliament in which position he was of course perfectly positioned to meet and discuss with people who helped shaped the Middle East such as Sir Mark Sykes and George Lloyd. Do you think his familiarity with the region, and its languages may have had any effect on these people who devised to carve up the Middle East, or were these schemes decided right at the top of French and British Government in a pre-designed order? From his writings do we know if Audrey Herbert was content and resigned with grand decisions being taken with little regard to the wishes of the populations on the ground?
Aubrey Herbert was a land-owner and the interests of his social class as such had a shrinking importance in British policy. Prominent industrialists were taking the lead, re-shaping the domestic and foreign policy according to their inexhaustible hunger of cheap or free raw and energy materials. Sectors of the aristocracy – Winston Churchill, for instance, and certainly George Curzon and David Lloyd George – shared their objectives and significantly contributed to build the political framework that allowed to achieve them. In spite of his dissent, Aubrey Herbert never questioned his obedience to the British government. He deplored the decisions that were taken, in particular the failed support to the Young Turks in 1908, but he never got to a breaking point. Great Britain was the framework, the structure, the horizon that he accepted as an incontrovertible fact. Nevertheless, being unaligned was also a structural feature of his character and education, therefore his dissent was irreducible and claimed expression even in the hardest contexts, as for instance during war times and even in the actual battlefield. I believe that Aubrey Herbert, had he lived longer, would have become a key-player in more representative and pluralistic institutions, where democracy is practiced in respect and integration of non-mainstream standpoints.
4- You listed 4 prominent individuals of the WWI and post period of people who opposed British Government aims in different ways: Gertrude Bell, Edmund Samuel Montagu, Audrey Herbert, Siegfried Sasson. Clearly they were all exceptional personalities and intellectuals in their own right living in the extra-ordinary time they lived. Could you crudely place them from today’s vantage point as being ‘anti-colonists’, or do you think this is an over-simplification?
Yes, I believe they were anti-colonialists ante-litteram because they believed in integration and not domination.
5- Edwin Montagu who as Secretary of State for India between 1917 and 1922 was an anti-Zionist Jew who opposed the Balfour declaration and also saw the folly of ‘depriving the Turk of Constantinople and the Sea of Marmara…’ with the occupation of those lands by the British post WWI as a consequence of Turkey siding with the central powers during WWI. Do we know if Audrey Herbert shared the same views and did these men correspond and re-enforce each other’s stances?
Excellent question! Unfortunately, I haven’t found out any evidence yet. I think that Herbert and Montague were two very different faces of dissent. Unlike consent, that is often driven by a centripetal force, dissent has a structural tendency to fragmentation.
6- How much of Audrey Herbert’s writings and diary were you able to access and what more is there for you to seek?
Unfortunately, I only read few passages of some of his writings. Should I continue my investigation of Aubrey Herbert, I will read more extensively his diary, his correspondence, but also what was written by his peers, in order to get a perception as precise as possible of his position in the wider framework.
7- Audrey Herbert after travelling on horseback in Ottoman controlled Macedonia ends up in Constantinople where he becomes ‘honorary military attaché’ in 1904 and from that position was able to contact and meet members of the Committee of Union and Progress who were to shape the nation in its evolution at the dying days of Empire. Do you think this connection allowed for him to have a privy of the working minds of the Young Turk movement better than almost any other outsider?
He was not the only sympathizer. Carlo Sforza was another great fan of the Committee, as certainly many other Europeans, who didn’t necessarily speak Turkish but nevertheless hanged out at the Cercle de l’Orient. Certainly, young Herbert’s diplomatic position allowed him to get in a closer touch with Young Turk leaders, whose discourse could be understood by him due to his language expertise. Nevertheless, other British functionaries who lived in Istanbul and had an even deeper knowledge of Turkish neither shared his enthusiasm for the principles of the Committee of Union and Progress nor frequented its leaders.
8- One of the most important politicians of the Young Turk movement was Talaat Pasha who served as a de-facto leader of the Ottoman Empire from 1913 to 1918. By chance Audrey Herbert and Talaat Pasha were in the same train in Germany, the latter being in exile in that country post WWI, shortly before his assassination by an Armenian squad for their revenge of what had happened in 1915 to their community. Do you think Audrey Herbert was ‘comfortable’ in associating in pleasant conversation with an individual who clearly had a big part to play in ordering massacres? Does this come from a sense of ‘loyalty of friendship’ trumping any of his moral doubts in your opinion?
They were not in the same train “by chance”. One month before the Conference of London (March 1921), Aubrey Herbert had been sent by Basil Thomson, the Director of British Intelligence, to meet the former Prime Minister in Germany apparently upon the latter’s request. He was instructed “to go and hear what he has to say without committing in any way”. Herbert stuck to the instructions, but made clear from the very moment when he accepted the task, that he would “act as I did on other occasions when I was asked to interview prominent Turks”. This sentence is interesting since it goes already in the direction of not considering Talaat as a “monster”, but as a representative of a leading class. In the report, written after the assassination, Aubrey Herbert does not express a judgement upon Talaat’s responsibilities, but clearly deplores that the memory of a “fearless” and “kindly” leader had to be “execrated”. More importantly, he openly denounces Bolshevik intelligence in his assassination, significantly occurring before an agreement between Great Britain and Turkey was to take place.
9- Gerald Fitzmaurice was the last chief dragoman of the British Embassy in Turkey and described Audrey Herbert’s fluency and deep knowledge of Turkish in his memoirs, but they clearly held different company, with Audrey Herbert frequently dining with members of the CUP. Do you get the impression that the British Embassy and the Foreign Office by ignoring this power centre allowed the German influence to fill that vacuum with its consequences just before WWI?
That who is able to answer this question will have the key to understand 20th-century European history! Unfortunately, I haven’t researched enough to give an exhaustive answer. Talaat and most Unionists certainly agreed with this theory, but personally I think that the situation was more complex. From the end of the 19th century, the Anglo-German competition had been a constant feature in Southern Europe and not only in the Ottoman Empire. Certainly, Great Britain’s failed backing to the Young Turks coup in 1908 gave indirect support to pro-German Enver faction, but this cannot lead to a direct cause-effect relationship. The Germans had operated huge investments in energy development and technological advancement that risked overcoming British economic leadership. From the beginning, their strategy towards the Ottoman world had been different from the British. We may say that competition was ongoing not only within the British and German industrial and military development but also in the respective way to relate with foreign societies. As in Giovanni Giolitti’s Italy, also in Young Turks’ Ottoman Empire there were different factions supporting either Britain or Germany.
10- The Italian politician Carlo Sforza was chargé d’affaires in Constantinople (1908-1909) where he witnessed the Young Turk Revolution and like Audrey Herbert hanged out with the CUP leaders causing a scandal. He was strongly anti-fascist and for that reason had to resign his later posting and later become an exile with the rise of Mussolini. Do we know how much Sforza and Herbert did also meet up and exchange views, and perhaps shape each other’s visions of how changes in Turkey could act as a stimulus to also bring about democratic reform in systems in their own country – at least for Sforza as we get the impression that for some reason Herbert as according to you the ‘issues of consent and representation back home did not have a particular relevance for him’?
Unfortunately, I haven’t found yet any evidence of their eventual relationship although I am quite sure they had one, either in Istanbul or, later, in the Balkans. Carlo Sforza in Italy had a stronger position that Aubrey Herbert in Great Britain. High Commissioner in Istanbul in 1918, he then became Minister of Foreign Affairs, whereas Aubrey Herbert was always kept in a marginal position at home. As I have already mentioned, dissent, unlike consent, presents multiple faces. Nevertheless, in spite of the different nationality and background, Herbert had more in common with Sforza than with Montagu. The Italian and British aristocrats completed their respective training in 1908 Istanbul, while occupying middle-ranked diplomatic positions that allowed them a degree of independence in considering Turkish affairs. Montagu, on the contrary, was State Secretary for India and dissent over British government’s guidelines cost him his position. As Herbert, Sforza also came from an old aristocrat family. He lived longer than Herbert but never really fitted into the Italian party system. Even after WW2, as he came back from the exile, he tried to stay as far as possible from any party membership, professing himself to be independent.
11- Audrey Herbert was a member of the Conservative party including under Lloyd George who clearly represented the ‘old Empire based order’. Yet his vision of the ‘Eastern Question’ was diametrically opposed to the policies pursued by this party during all this period. Do you think Audrey Herbert was able to compartmentalise this internal tension and feel no moral angst?
Aubrey Herbert never lost an occasion to express his views and he openly despised Lloyd George’s political vision. This extroverted attitude eased, I think, his moral angst. Moreover, he was above all a man of action who tried in all and any circumstance to demonstrate with principles-driven facts that another way was possible and preferable. He certainly compartmentalised, also thanks to the wide spectrum of relationships he entertained. For example, in the battlefield, in front of the slaughter perpetrated by machineguns, he was able to write letters to his half-sister Vera describing the wild birds’ diverse behavioural patterns in the midst of the racket caused by explosions.
12- Talaat Pasha in his conversation with Audrey Herbert talked about his disappointment of the lack of British support during the 1908 revolution and thus ‘drove them to the arms of Germany’. Do you think this is Talaat Pasha perhaps making excuses for later excesses as the Young Turks at the time would have also resented ‘foreign interference’ which was one of the guiding factors in the vision of this movement?
Interesting question! I also think that fine politician as he was, Talaat was playing his best cards to support the ongoing peace process and marginalise Enver’s faction. He knew that his meeting with Herbert could be his last chance to direct events and he was too clever to lose time with unnecessary sincere arguments. As I answered to question 9, the events occurred in 1908 created a watershed: for the first time in history the Ottoman Empire was guided by men that the West could not but recognise as a modern leading class. WW1 resulted from the different ways in which Great Britain and Germany reacted to that.
13- Between 1911-4 Audrey Herbert campaigned and advocated for Albanian independence yet saw no conflict of interest with his pledge of support for the Young Turk movement. Do you think Audrey Herbert was also a ‘romantic’ by portraying the Muslims of Albania as being ‘an alloy to a long-lasting co-existence among different religions in the Balkans’, when he also knew the brewing Balkan wars would hurt the local Muslim populations the most?
Maybe he was realistic. He knew that the Muslim communities were the depositary of a brand of cohesive government tradition, whereas the hegemony of foreign-supported Orthodox (Serbian) communities would have led to intra-communitarian unbalance and violence.
14- In March 1921 the Kemalists and Bolsheviks signed the treaty of Moscow. A month before there was a conference in London where Bekir Sami (minister of foreign affairs) on behalf of the Kemalists proposed a peace treaty with the Greeks but this was unsuccessful. Bekir Sami was clearly working under the instructions of Talaat Pasha but do you think Audrey Herbert also acted as an advisor in the background? Did the Allies fail to curb the ambitions of Greece and allow Russia to become a strategic ally of Turkey for a long period with this short-sightedness?
Yes! To all questions!
15- Will a book eventually result from your continuing research on Aubrey Herbert?
I don’t think that historical biographies are a genre of crucial importance for today’s historiography. Nevertheless, as I have tried to explain, Aubrey Herbert’s perspective on eastern affairs will always be of paradigmatic relevance for my research and I am planning to spend a few weeks in Somerset, working on his personal archive.
