Vladimir Hamed-Troyansky online presentation: ‘Empire of Refugees: North Caucasian Muslims and the Late Ottoman State’, 7 October 2024 - flyer:
1- Please tell us more about your academic biography and research interests.
I am a historian of migration in the Ottoman and Russian empires. I am broadly interested in Muslim refugee migration and its role in shaping the contemporary Middle East, the Caucasus, and the Balkans. My research is grounded in archival sources in Ottoman Turkish, Arabic, and Russian. I received a Ph.D. in History from Stanford University, held a postdoctoral fellowship at Columbia University, and now serve as Assistant Professor of Global Studies at the University of California, Santa Barbara.
2- What motivated your interest in the displacement of Muslims from the North Caucasus to the Ottoman Empire?
I started my research on Muslim displacement from the Caucasus after I came across rare archival documents—detailed nineteenth-century Ottoman registers about financial aid given to Circassian refugees—in archives in Istanbul and Sofia. As I dug deeper in my research, I realized that, while many know about the existence of the Circassian communities in Turkey, Jordan, and Syria, little is known about how the North Caucasian diaspora—one of the largest in the Middle East— came to be: through devastating displacement from the Russian Empire and grueling resettlement throughout the Ottoman Empire.
My book, Empire of Refugees: North Caucasian Muslims and the Late Ottoman State (Stanford University Press, 2024), examines the resettlement of about a million refugees from the North Caucasus in the Ottoman Empire. It explores the origins of organized refugee resettlement in the modern Middle East. The book is based on extensive archival research in over 20 public and private archives in 10 countries: Turkey, Bulgaria, Jordan, Romania, Georgia, Armenia, Azerbaijan, the United Kingdom, the United States, and Russian, including the autonomous republics of Kabardino-Balkaria, North Ossetia-Alania, and Dagestan.
3- Why did so many North Caucasians Muslims become refugees to the Ottoman Empire?
Between the 1850s and World War I, over a million Muslims from the North Caucasus became refugees in the Ottoman Empire. The reason for their displacement was Russia’s conquest of the Caucasus. In the final stage of the Caucasus War (1817–64), the Russian military perpetrated an ethnic cleansing of Circassians, which led to the flight of about half-a-million western Circassians as refugees to the Ottoman Empire.
Muslim emigration from the North Caucasus continued after the end of the war. Many Chechens, Ingush, Kabardians (eastern Circassians), Ossetians, Balkars, Karachays, Avars, and others emigrated to the Ottoman Empire between 1864 and 1914. Many of them were pushed out by Russia’s reforms, including land reforms, which dispossessed many Muslim communities and accelerated colonization of the region by Slavic settlers.
The Ottoman government welcomed Muslim refugees escaping Russia. Empire of Refugees shows that the Ottoman government constructed a refugee regime, predating refugee systems set up by the League of Nations and the United Nations in the twentieth century. The Ottoman refugee regime guaranteed admission and resettlement to all Muslim refugees and the guarantee of free land, exemptions from taxation and military service, and financial aid. The Refugee Commission, founded in 1860, resettled North Caucasian refugees in almost every Ottoman province in the Balkans, Anatolia, and the Levant. North Caucasian refugees were settled in territories of today’s 14 nation-states. By 1914, they established over a thousand new refugee villages in Anatolia, the Levant, and Iraq.
4- How did North Caucasian refugees transform the Ottoman Empire?
The arrival of Muslim refugees from the North Caucasus accelerated the transformation of Ottoman demographics. In the nineteenth century, the Ottoman Empire was becoming more Muslim than ever before. On the one hand, many Muslim refugees arrived from territories occupied by the Russian Empire and from the former Ottoman territories in the Balkans. Between three and five million Muslim refugees arrived in the Ottoman Empire between the Crimean War (1853–56) and World War I. On the other hand, the empire was losing Ottoman Christians, who either became citizens of new nation-states in the Balkans or were emigrating to the Americas or Russia. In the 1820s, 60 percent of Ottoman population was Muslim. By 1914, it was 81 percent.
The resettlement of North Caucasian refugees created tensions over land throughout the empire. In accordance with the Ottoman refugee regime, grounded in the Immigration Law of 1857 and the Land Code of 1858, the government gave refugees free plots of agricultural land. That land was often taken from communities who had failed to cultivate it or to pay tax on it. Refugees often had to defend their right to that land by force or in court. My book examines some of the conflicts over land between North Caucasian refugees and Turkic-speaking nomads in central Anatolia, the Druze in the Golan Heights, and bedouin in Transjordan.
The settlement of Circassian refugees transformed many areas of the Middle East but nowhere was it is as impactful as in Ottoman Transjordan — an arid region, which served as the southernmost area of refugee resettlement in the Ottoman Empire. Circassians and Chechens established eight refugee villages in Transjordan. They include three of the four largest cities in modern Jordan. Amman, which has the population of over 4 million people and is currently the largest city in the Levant, was established as a Circassian refugee village in 1878. By utilizing Ottoman land registers and court records, my book reconstructs the origin story of Amman. I show that Amman rose in prominence thanks to the convergence of Circassian refugee labor, Palestinian and Syrian merchant capital, and bedouin land and agriculture.
5- What is the situation of the North Caucasian diaspora in modern Turkey?
The North Caucasian diaspora in the Middle East comprises up to 3 million people in Turkey, where they are the largest non-Turkish minority after the Kurds and the Syrians, up to 100,000 in Syria, over 50,000 in Jordan, and smaller communities exist in Iraq, Israel, Libya, Tunisia, Egypt, and other countries.
In modern Turkey, many know its large North Caucasian community by the identity of its largest part — “Circassian” (Çerkes). In Turkey, between 1923 and the 1950s, North Caucasians could not freely express their non-Turkish identities because of the Kemalist emphasis on Turkishness. Turkification has been very strong, with much of the North Caucasian diaspora speaking Turkish as their native language. Yet, despite strong assimilation policies by the state, the preservation of North Caucasian cultural heritage is remarkable, especially in isolated rural regions of Anatolia. In recent decades, North Caucasian activists established dozens of diasporic associations in Turkish cities to promote the preservation of their languages and traditions.
6- What is the North Caucasian diaspora’s relationship with its homeland?
The fundamentals of North Caucasian diasporic politics and identity have been set in the late Ottoman era. In 1908, diasporic intellectuals in Istanbul established the Circassian Union and Support Association, which became the dominant diasporic organization for North Caucasians until 1923. This organization promoted pride in one’s ethnic (Circassian, Chechen, Ossetian, etc.) identity as well as national (Ottoman) identity. After the collapse of the Ottoman Empire, the North Caucasian diasporic world has been fragmented, and refugee communities forged different relations with their new nation-states. Eventually, new diasporic organizations emerged, including the Federation of Caucasian Associations in Turkey, the Circassian Charity Association in Jordan, the Circassian Charity Association in Syria, and the Charitable Solidarity Association of Chechens, Dagestanis, and Circassians of Iraq. They have a similar objective to their Ottoman predecessor: to maintain ethnic identities by preserving their culture, while stressing their national identity (Turkish, Jordanian, Syrian, or Iraqi) and commitment to their nation-states.
The North Caucasian diaspora’s relationship with its homeland has been evolving since the 1990s. During the Soviet era, the diaspora’s communication with, or travel to, the North Caucasus was largely impossible. After the collapse of the Soviet Union, many North Caucasians in the Middle East could visit their ancestral homeland for the first time since their displacement in the nineteenth century. It was a deeply meaningful moment for many families. Several thousand individuals repatriated to the autonomous North Caucasus republics within the Russian Federation. However, the integration process was difficult for repatriates because of the red tape, high crime in the 1990s, Russification of North Caucasus societies, and a lack of integration programs. The Russian government refuses to recognize the mass right of return for descendants of North Caucasian refugees of the nineteenth century, which many in the diaspora see as a matter of historical justice.
7- What are you working on now?
My new book project is a transnational history of hijra in modern Eurasia. By exploring refugee migrations from the Balkans, the Caucasus, Central Asia, and South Asia, I aim to demonstrate how Muslim displacement was central to state-building and nation-making in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries.
When writing my first book, it became clear to me that hijra, or Muslim refugee migration, was a global phenomenon. Hijra originally denotes the journey of the Prophet Muhammad from Mecca to Medina in 622 CE. By the nineteenth century, many Muslim communities that had been displaced by European empires and fled to the Ottoman Empire spoke of their journey as hijra and of themselves as muhajir — a term that can be translated as a refugee, immigrant, or emigrant. This language remains meaningful to many refugees throughout the Muslim world to this day. It evokes a distinct genealogy of knowledge about displacement and survival.